A 4.2 quake north of St. Thomas, and the 1867 tsunami that struck as the islands were being sold
In 1867 a tsunami struck while Denmark was selling St. Thomas and St. John to the United States. The islanders voted for the sale, the only time they officially did, and the U.S. Senate never took it up.
By Brian Louden · · VI Update
At 5:06 a.m., a day after the anniversary of the 1867 earthquake and tsunami, the sea floor north of St. Thomas shifted again, and some Virgin Islanders felt their windows rattle.
The earthquake measured magnitude 4.2, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. It struck about 36 miles north-northeast of Charlotte Amalie, roughly 31 miles down. More than 20 people reported light shaking to the USGS. Nothing was reported damaged, and the quake was too small for the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center to issue a message.
The one that came on Monday, November 18, 1867, 159 years ago, was not small. Its tsunami stopped the sale of the islands to the United States 50 years before that sale took place, at the only time the people of the islands officially voted for it themselves.
A delicate moment
Denmark had agreed to sell St. Thomas and St. John to the United States for $7.5 million, and the people of the two islands were about to vote on it. St. Croix was not part of the deal. The Danish king's commissioner had landed the day before to prepare the sale, and American warships were waiting in the harbor to take control: for the trade, or maybe something else. By nightfall, the vote would be the last thing on anyone's mind.
The islands were Danish then, and they were already hurting. A hurricane had torn through just 20 days earlier, and St. Thomas writer Charles Edwin Taylor later put its death toll on that island at more than 300.
The wave at Charlotte Amalie
It came in the middle of the afternoon. No record agrees on the exact minute. On St. Thomas, the newspaper found its office clock stopped at about ten past three and used that time.
Rear Admiral J. S. Palmer was working in his cabin aboard the USS Susquehanna. His warship shook for about two minutes. Palmer decided it was over and went back to his papers. Ten minutes later, a crew member told him the sea was rising. From the deck he saw, about 3 miles out, a wall of water roughly 20 feet high moving toward the harbor.
A St. Thomas resident named Otto Frederick Raupach watched it come. He described a white wall, perfectly straight, "as if built with the aid of a rule."
The rocky points at the harbor mouth took some of its strength. The rest went up the main street of Charlotte Amalie. Every store from the King's Wharf down stood in 4 to 5 feet of ocean, and sailboats that had been in the harbor sat on the streets.
When the water backed out, the harbor nearly emptied, and people saw fish lying on the sand. Ten minutes later a second wave came in, a little larger than the first.
The American warship De Soto was thrown onto the iron posts of a new wharf, then lifted off again by the next wave. Afloat, her crew got the engines going and steamed for the harbor mouth to pull people from overturned boats. Samuel Watlington, 20 years old, drowned in that harbor trying to save his father.
Frederiksted
Across the channel on St. Croix, Frederiksted had no reef to protect it. Witnesses said the sea pulled back until they could see the bottom beyond the anchored ships. It came back as a dark wall. People ran for the hills, carrying the elderly through the streets.
The USS Monongahela was anchored off the town. Commodore S. B. Bissell reported the wave picked up his ship and carried it over the warehouses into the first street. When the sea fell away, the Monongahela was sitting on a reef at the water's edge. One of her officers later wrote that the ship rode so high on the wave that not a drop came over her deck.
At what was called a salt lake near Frederiksted, a woman known as Queen Dalphina was gathering wood with her son when the wave hit. She lost her life; her son entered legend. The story has a few tellings. The most reasonable today is a letter to the St. Croix Avis, which reported that the boy caught the tail of a pony ridden by a Monongahela sailor, and the pony carried them both to high ground. In the others, as some tell it, the boy lived because the spirits of the Virgin Islands gave their protection in trade for the mother, and in the legend recorded, the child was saved by a wild deer.
The vote, and the wait
Raupach kept counting. He felt 89 aftershocks in the first 12 hours. For days afterward, families camped in tents on the hills above Charlotte Amalie, especially those whose stone houses the earthquake had damaged. Stone homes were common outside the towns, and many at the time thought them safer.
The vote on the sale was pushed to January. Each voter on St. Thomas was handed two tickets, blue for the sale and white against it. St. Thomas voted yes, 1,039 to 22. St. John voted 205 to none.
The U.S. Senate never took it up, and the treaty expired in 1870. The Monongahela made it back to sea in May 1868 with the help of Virgin Islanders, and the fort at Frederiksted fired 21 guns in salute. The islands themselves waited, becoming American on March 31, 1917, with no official vote of their own.
Whether the earthquake cost that half century is still argued. In 1891, a U.S. naval commander named Barker said it did. In 1918, former U.S. vice-consul Luther Zabriskie pointed to Washington instead, where interest had simply faded and President Andrew Johnson was at war with the Senate.
What has not changed
A 2015 proclamation from the Governor's office warned that a wave like this can arrive within 10 minutes, faster than any official alert can be triggered. Strong or long shaking near the shore is the warning. Go uphill. Do not stay to watch the fish on the sand.
Analysis
Barker blamed the earth itself. Zabriskie blamed Washington, apathy and distraction.
The people of the islands saw the value in a different colonial power at the time. But the buyer had warships in the harbor one day, and was gone the next. In the modern vernacular, they ghosted them.
The question
What would it mean to you, the people of the Virgin Islands, if it had been your vote that made you an American?
And for those throughout the Caribbean and in territories elsewhere in the world, some of whom had a say and most of whom had little to none: what does your island, territory or country's relationship look like with the power that governs it, foreign or not, and how do you feel about how its story began?