For a month, the government's spending website stood still

The site the law requires to show how the Virgin Islands government spends public money stayed online and showed nothing new. Nothing on it said the data had stopped, and anyone looking had no way to know it was a month behind.

By Brian Louden · · VI Update

For one month this fall, the website the law requires to show how the Virgin Islands government spends public money showed nothing new. The site stayed online. The checks and the payroll behind it stopped.

The site is transparency.vi.gov. It carries two things: a checkbook of vendor payments, and the government payroll. VI Update has kept copies of the checkbook since March and the payroll since June. Since September 10, its system has copied both twice a day.

What stopped

Through the first half of October, the checkbook grew on every business day. On the evening of October 17, it stopped. There was no public announcement, no warning, no sign at all.

For the next month, every read returned the same 191 entries, none dated after October 16. Two copies taken three days apart were identical down to the last byte: the same file, unchanged.

Payroll stopped at the same time. The regular payrolls expected October 29 and November 12 never appeared.

Not how the site normally behaves

Before the freeze, the checkbook never went more than three days without a new entry. At every check VI Update made from March through September, the newest entry was no more than four days old. By November 13, the newest was 28 days old.

Nothing on the site, or on the Office of Management and Budget or Department of Finance websites, said the data had stopped. Anyone looking saw a working site, with no way to know it was a month behind.

What the law says

The Virgin Islands Government Transparency Act, Title 3, section 881a of the Virgin Islands Code, assigns the site to the Bureau of Information Technology, working with OMB and Finance. It says the data "must be updated on a monthly basis, at a minimum." It makes no exception for maintenance, a rebuild, or the close of a fiscal year. It does not define monthly.

What came back

On November 17, the checkbook came back, 31 days after the last change. By the next day it listed more than 1,100 entries, with the missing weeks filled in.

The update showed how incomplete the frozen file had been. For October 1 through 16, the frozen site showed $2.9 million. It now lists $15.5 million for those same dates, changed in a single update.

The closed fiscal year changed too. The same update added 2,025 late entries to fiscal year 2026, nearly all from September, listed at about $37.8 million. During the freeze, none of them were on the site.

Payroll came back last, sometime between the afternoon of November 18 and the afternoon of November 19: 32 or 33 days. By then, the October 29 payroll was three weeks old.

No answers

On November 13, VI Update emailed Finance Commissioner Kevin McCurdy and OMB Director Julio Rhymer and asked whether the site was still being updated. On November 16, it emailed Bureau of Information Technology Director Rupert Ross with four questions, including why publication stopped and which office is responsible for the monthly update. The same night, it filed a public records request with Finance for the missing data and for any records explaining the stop.

As of Friday morning, November 20, none of the three had replied. The records request had not been acknowledged. No executive branch office VI Update has questioned has answered it in months.

The government's site now looks complete. The copies VI Update took during the freeze are the only record it knows of that shows the site stood still.

The rebuild

In February, Director Rhymer told WTJX the government was working on the site, "as we rebuild the site." VI Update has found no notice since then saying the site was being rebuilt, paused, or delayed.

What the checks can and cannot see

VI Update's twice-daily checks began September 10. They cannot see the moment of a change. A change is recorded as having happened between two of those checks, when it first shows up. VI Update does not know why the data stopped, or why it came back.

What comes next

The next regular payroll is due around November 26. The records request is still pending, and the law sets no deadline for an answer and no requirement to enforce a penalty. The Bryan administration leaves office January 4. VI Update's system still reads both feeds twice a day, and will report it if they stop again.

Analysis

That silence leaves the record to speak. The law requires an update every month. It says nothing about telling the public when the updates stop. It should.

One view is that the data is back, the missing weeks are filled in, and 31 days is close enough to monthly. The other is that the law says monthly at a minimum, the public got no notice, and two payrolls sat off the site for weeks.

Editor's note

VI Update's brief on the freeze, "The month the spending site stood still": https://viupdate.com/reports/spending-site-stood-still/. The copies taken during the freeze, as a data package: https://viupdate.com/reports/data/gvi-spending-site-freeze-data/. Both pages link their permanent Zenodo copies. The text of 3 V.I.C. § 881a: https://usvipublicrecords.com/law/code/title-3#s-881a

The question

Is a month of silence on the public's own spending data, with no way to know it isn't current, acceptable to you?