Sarauw asks her new House class for a delegate vote on final passage

U.S. Virgin Islanders have been American citizens for 99 years, and their delegate has never once voted on whether a bill becomes law. The incoming delegate says a vote may be closer than it looks.

By Brian Louden · · VI Update

Delegate-elect Janelle Sarauw says she has asked her incoming class in Congress to back a vote for the territory's delegate on final passage of bills. No territorial delegate has ever cast one.

What Sarauw said

Sarauw is in Washington for New Member Orientation ahead of the 120th Congress. In a video posted to Facebook on November 12, she says she raised the delegate's missing vote with her entire incoming class during a Democratic caucus session.

A fellow incoming member appears on camera beside her and describes how the room responded:

"We all clap."

Applause is not a vote, but Sarauw says a vote may be closer than it looks. She says she was meeting with the delegates-elect from Washington, D.C., and Guam about what she called a loophole, a strategy to win over her class, the Congressional Black Caucus and the wider House. Her class, she said, makes up a fifth of Congress. Published counts put it at 109 or more incoming House freshmen, the largest incoming class in decades.

Combined with sitting Democrats, she said, "we have the votes to have a final vote on the floor."

She did not say what the strategy involves. VI Update has not seen any count of members committed to it.

How rights reached the territory

Each right in the U.S. territories came by act of Congress, one piece at a time, decades apart. For these Americans, citizenship and self-government come from laws Congress wrote, not from the Constitution, and Congress can rewrite them.

The United States bought these islands in 1917. Congress did not make the people here citizens until 1927; for a decade, they were American nationals without American citizenship. Presidents appointed the governor until 1970. Congress created the delegate's seat in 1972, with a voice in the House and no vote.

A vote that could not decide anything

Since 1993, Democratic majorities have let delegates vote on amendments in what the House calls the Committee of the Whole. Republican majorities took that vote away in 1995 and 2011.

Even when it existed, it came with a catch. Any time the delegates' votes decided the outcome, the House voted again without them. The Congressional Research Service called that vote "largely symbolic," and a federal court upheld the rule on the same reasoning.

No territorial delegate has ever cast a vote on final passage of a bill. That is what Sarauw is asking for.

The constitutional obstacle

The obstacle is in the Constitution itself, which says House members are chosen by the people of the several states. In 2007, the House passed a bill giving the D.C. delegate a full vote. It died in the Senate. The Congressional Research Service concluded that Congress likely lacks the power to grant that vote by ordinary law.

The other half: a vote for president

A floor vote would answer only half the question. A Virgin Islander who moves to Florida can vote for president as soon as they register. If they move home, that vote is gone.

D.C. residents won the presidential vote through the 23rd Amendment in 1961. For the territories, it would likely take a constitutional amendment or statehood. Sarauw did not raise the presidential vote in her video.

The Insular Cases

The legal foundation for all of this is a set of Supreme Court decisions from 1901 known as the Insular Cases. They have never been overturned. In 2022, Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote that they rest on the racial prejudice of their era and should be overruled. The Court did not take that step.

A bill already in Congress

In July 2025, Virgin Islands Delegate Stacey Plaskett and Guam Delegate James Moylan filed H.R. 4292, a bipartisan proposal for a congressional task force on voting rights in the territories.

Both sides

In 2011, Speaker John Boehner's office said delegates should not vote in the Committee of the Whole, because they constitutionally cannot vote on the House floor.

Sarauw's colleague in the clip put the other side in nine words:

"If it ain't for all, it ain't at all."

The question

Should the territory's delegate get a vote on final passage, and should a vote for president come with it? It is a question for Virgin Islanders at home and across the diaspora, and for the people of Puerto Rico, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands and American Samoa.