How a three-page lab recipe from 2011 reached 150 countries

The butterfly effect is usually told as a story no one can check. This one has a paper trail: a blue petri dish written down by an undergraduate in Texas now sits one or two steps upstream of more than 11,000 scientific papers.

By Brian Louden · · VI Update

A three-page laboratory method written by an undergraduate in Texas in 2011 sits, fifteen years later, one or two steps upstream of more than 11,000 scientific papers in 150 countries. Its impact touches disease tracking, food scarcity and cancer research.

The method is a recipe for a blue petri dish. Brian Louden wrote it down as an undergraduate studying microbiology at Sam Houston State University in Texas, simply because he was tired of getting it wrong.

The blue plate

The test is called the CAS assay. It shows whether a microbe is scavenging iron. Iron is scarce in soil, in seawater and in the human body, so bacteria release small molecules called siderophores to grab it. On a CAS plate the agar is blue. When a microbe pulls the iron out, it leaves an orange halo.

The test was invented in 1987 by Bernhard Schwyn and J. B. Neilands. It was not Louden's discovery; the problem was making it. The original procedure, as the 2011 paper later put it, was "written in general terms and can be difficult to follow." Louden worked out every step until the plates came out right.

His mentor, Dr. Aaron Lynne, told him, in so many words, that he had already done the hard part. If he did a little more and gave it away, the next person would have less work, and he would get a publication. Lynne, Daniel Haarmann and Louden wrote it up. The American Society for Microbiology's teaching journal published it in May 2011, free to read.

The flap of the wings

In 1972, the meteorologist Edward Lorenz asked whether the flap of a butterfly's wings in Brazil could set off a tornado in Texas. This one flapped in Texas. Today, 20 papers from Brazil cite it.

For five years, it barely moved. Through 2016, 19 papers cited it. In 2017, 22 cited it in a single year. In 2025, 100 did.

The first ring: papers that cite it

On November 14, Louden pulled the citation record from five scientific databases. The open index OpenAlex counts 641 papers that cite the recipe directly, from 955 institutions in 78 countries. Of the 1,621 articles the journal has published, it is the most cited.

India uses it most, followed by the United States and China. Roughly two thirds of the work is agriculture: labs screening soil bacteria that could stand in for chemical fertilizer or protect rice, tomato, wheat and maize from disease.

The rest reaches further. It is cited in a study tracking a Klebsiella outbreak in a New York City hospital, in a study engineering bacteria against cancer, and this year in Nature Biotechnology, in work using bacteria to break down rock and pull carbon from the air. It is written into 15 patent families in 7 countries, including filings by Harvard University.

The second ring: methods passed hand to hand

Science passes methods hand to hand. A lab reads a paper that used the recipe and cites that paper instead. Another 1,589 siderophore papers sit one step downstream without citing the recipe itself. Counted with them, the footprint reaches 107 countries.

The same thing happens off the record. A 2021 student poster at the University of Puerto Rico at Mayagüez screened soils from Cabo Rojo with the blue plate. It cites a 2017 paper that cites the recipe twice.

The third ring: reach, not use

Every paper that cites any of the first 641, on any subject, adds up to 11,239 papers. Together with the first ring, their authors work in 150 countries. Most of them cite their neighbor for its findings, not for the blue plate. They are still downstream of it.

A personal note

This is a vanity project. The butterfly effect is usually a story no one can check; this one has a paper trail, and I happen to be an investigative journalist, so I measured it. It tells the story of how knowledge travels through science itself.

I fixed it for myself, and then I moved on and forgot about it. None of those labs needed me. The method already existed. What changed is that the steps were written down clearly and given away, and each paper that used them handed them to the next.

Some people would say a small fix like this matters only to the person who made it. Aaron's view was that the small fix is exactly what travels. That lesson lives on in my work today.

What have you figured out for yourself that you never shared, and what might it do if you did?