Two governors argue over a WAPA emergency. The tools closest to the machines need no declaration
Four new generators bought for St. John have sat in storage on St. Thomas since August. None of the tools in the emergency argument can fix a broken engine, and the ones closest to the machines need no declaration at all.
By Brian Louden · · VI Update
Governor-elect Stacey Plaskett says she will declare a WAPA emergency on January 4, the day she takes office, and she wants Governor Albert Bryan Jr. to declare one now.
"Letters do not generate electricity," Plaskett said in a statement on November 18.
Bryan says the territory already has the federal money, help and generators it needs, and that WAPA needs time.
"Fixing WAPA takes more than declaring an emergency," Bryan said on November 19.
Four new generators bought for St. John have sat in storage on St. Thomas since August. The two governors are arguing over an emergency declaration, and none of the tools in that argument can fix a broken engine.
Where the power stands
St. Thomas and St. John get their power from one plant at Krum Bay, the Randolph Harley plant. Its largest unit, Unit 23, has a failed gearbox, and WAPA says it may not return until late 2027 or 2028. Unit 15 is out until at least January. As of November 19, three of the four newer Wartsila engines were down. In June, WAPA told the EPA it has no backup generation.
By VI Update's estimate from WAPA's own figures, Harley can make about 45 megawatts on a day when the district needs close to 60. St. Croix lost power islandwide three times in five days this month, and St. Thomas and St. John residents now notice when the power is on, more than they notice when it is out.
VI Update put one question to every tool in the argument: does it make a machine run?
The territorial declaration
A territorial declaration under Title 23, section 1005 of the Virgin Islands Code lets a governor set aside local procedures and permit steps for 30 days, renew once, then go to the Legislature. It also opens the Rainy Day Fund without a vote of the Legislature.
Bryan used it exactly that way in 2024, and the government checkbook shows about 17 million dollars paid from the fund to WAPA for overdue bills. WAPA's cash gap narrowed. The rolling blackouts continued. The fund held 14.6 million dollars in early August, and about half of that has since gone out or been set aside.
WAPA already buys emergency parts without bidding under its own law. A territorial declaration moves money. It does not move an engine.
A federal Stafford Act declaration
A federal Stafford Act declaration reaches further, and it can put uniforms on the ground. Under a federal emergency, FEMA can send the Army Corps of Engineers to put temporary generators on hospitals, water pumps and other critical buildings. After the 2017 hurricanes, the Corps powered a pumping station half of St. Croix depended on for water.
It does not fix the plant. FEMA's rules exclude deferred maintenance, and FEMA's records show no major disaster has ever been declared for a power outage alone. Plaskett has tied a federal declaration to disaster food aid, which requires a major disaster with federal help for individual households. Before January 4, only Bryan can ask.
Separately, a 2024 law, Act 8869, ordered WAPA to seek technical help from the Army Corps and the Department of Energy and to deliver a modernization plan. VI Update found no record of that plan.
An Energy Department emergency order
The tool closest to the machines is the one Plaskett asked WAPA's board to pursue in an October 25 letter: an emergency order from the U.S. Department of Energy under section 202(c) of the Federal Power Act. DOE can order units to run and approve temporary connections, and what the utility does to comply is not treated as a violation of environmental law. It fixes nothing broken, but it can clear the way for equipment that works.
Puerto Rico has lived under these orders since May 2025, and Guam got one in August, a day after it applied. WAPA, the Public Services Commission or the governor can apply, without an emergency declaration. Energy Department records show no application from the Virgin Islands.
The EPA waiver
Bryan has said a declaration could help get an EPA waiver for new generation. It does not need one. Under section 325 of the Clean Air Act, the governor can petition EPA directly. In 2003, Governor Charles Turnbull did, and the EPA let WAPA build Unit 23 before its federal air permit came through, on the condition that it not run until permitted. No one has filed that petition for the new units.
The St. John generators
Those four generators, 10 megawatts bought with about 8 million dollars in FEMA money, have sat at Harley through every district-wide blackout since August. Because FEMA is paying, they need a federal coastal review that no local proclamation can waive. The local coastal permit can already be waived in an emergency, with no proclamation. VI Update found no request for that waiver in the coastal filings or the hearing record.
Parts, repairs and permits
What actually makes machines run is parts, repairs and permits. On November 19, WAPA chief Karl Knight told his board that WAPA has finally reached a maintenance agreement with Wartsila, and that another engine may be fixed by December 6. In April, Knight told senators that WAPA has covered its money shortfalls for over a decade by deferring maintenance.
Underneath the machines is the money. The Legislature's Post Audit Division found WAPA's fuel costs ran more than 147 million dollars ahead of its fuel charge from fiscal 2021 through 2025. WAPA has no audited financial statements on record since fiscal 2020.
Analysis
I tracked at least 14 dated promises of new or temporary generation since 2019. Of the ten whose first date has passed, not one was running by their deadline.
No declaration fixes the fuel charge, the maintenance or the books. The tools closest to the machines need no declaration at all, and I found no filing for any of them.
Plaskett says a declaration brings federal resources and faster permits. Bryan says WAPA needs time to finish repairs, not a declaration.