WAPA's own outage map, saved every five minutes, is now a public record

St. Thomas and St. John have long said they have it worse. By WAPA's own map, they do, and for the first time the map's account can be checked against WAPA's.

By Brian Louden · · VI Update

From March 23 to November 7, VI Update saved the data behind the Water and Power Authority's public outage map every five minutes. That record is now public and free, with a forty-three page report on what it shows.

What the record is

It is more than 65,000 snapshots of WAPA's own account of its outages, kept exactly as WAPA published it, when WAPA published it.

It is not a direct measurement of who had power; that is planned. It is WAPA's live map, generated by WAPA's own systems and preserved by someone other than WAPA, so its truth can be checked against WAPA's.

St. Thomas and St. John have it worse

St. Thomas and St. John have long said they have it worse. By WAPA's own map, they do. Of all the time customers spent without power on the map, nearly nine hours in every ten fell on St. Thomas and St. John. That works out to about eight full days without power per customer, or 3.8% of the time with the lights off.

On St. Croix, it was about a day and a quarter, or a little over half a percent. Those per-customer figures are estimates, because WAPA does not publish how many customers each district has. The gap between the islands is not.

A typical outage stayed on the map about 2 hours and 15 minutes on St. Thomas and St. John before appearing restored. On St. Croix it took a little over an hour.

When the map and WAPA disagree

That is how long an outage stayed on the map, which is not always when the power came back. On August 11, WAPA said power was restored at about 7:51 in the morning. More than 25,000 customers stayed on the map until 8:42, over 50 minutes later.

Sometimes the map runs small. On April 30, WAPA declared an outage across St. Croix. The map never showed more than about a third of the island out.

Sometimes it does not run at all. For nine days this summer, from July 24 to August 2, the map was frozen on the same answer. On the night of July 29, in the middle of that freeze, WAPA texted customers that all of St. Croix was out. On the map, nothing changed.

Those disagreements run in both directions. The point is not that one side is always right. The point is that now it can be checked.

A history WAPA rewrites

WAPA's map also carries an hourly history of the last forty-eight hours. WAPA does not keep it public, and it changes it after the fact: in about one hour of every six, by a thousand customers or more. Correcting a record can be legitimate. WAPA does not publish how, or why.

On October 19, the map held at 2,031 customers out on St. Thomas and St. John for more than eight hours. WAPA's later history for those same hours counts about 35 customers across the entire territory. Either about 2,000 people sat in the dark overnight and the record dropped them, or the map showed people out who were not out to begin with.

Nobody outside WAPA can say which. Until this record, the first version simply disappeared. Now both are kept uneditable in Switzerland, thanks to CERN.

What the map does not tell you

What the map says about a feeder is less fixed than it looks. On May 14, the number of customers WAPA counts jumped by more than four thousand in five minutes, and feeders are switched from day to day.

In seven and a half months and 7,433 outage records, the map never once told anyone when their power would be back. WAPA has never used that function.

What officials have said

On November 9, with rolling blackouts still running on St. Thomas and St. John, Governor Bryan said of WAPA: "This is a horrible way for me to leave Government House." He says repairs at the Harley plant could end those blackouts in about two weeks.

Governor-elect Stacey Plaskett, still the territory's delegate, was scheduled for Department of Energy meetings that week. She says that on January 4, the day she takes office, she will declare a state of emergency over WAPA and ask the Department of Energy and the White House for help.

Analysis

Everyone in the Virgin Islands has a WAPA story: the food that spoiled, the business that closed in the middle of the day, the medical equipment whose battery never had time to recharge between outages. The hard part has always been proving it. Now there is a record to hold it against.

My hope is that someone smarter than me does something with the data. The question I keep coming back to is whether seeing what we all knew, written down unchanged, is vindication, or whether it just makes it worse, knowing it still isn't fixed and we are measuring in decades.

About this report

You do not have to take my word for any of this. The raw data is public, and a program that comes with it reruns 4,758 checks on the report's numbers. Every one passes.

AI coding tools helped build and ran the research programs on my computer, under my direction. I set the rules, make the decisions, and choose the analysis and tests. The report includes no interviews or comment, and WAPA is welcome to answer any of it.

The report and the full data files are free at viupdate.com/reports. Using the report just needs credit to my name. The data I give away without restriction.

On November 9, I sent this record to Governor-elect Plaskett and Delegate-elect Janelle Sarauw. Neither had replied to my email when the segment aired.

Read the report: What WAPA's outage map recorded