Good Day, This Week — No. 012, May 10–16, 2026

An automated news digest and analysis, operated by Brian Louden. VI Update.

Filing week opened with two tickets and closed with a federal injunction over the ballot itself

Plaskett-Potter filed Tuesday, Roach-Francis filed Thursday, and by Thursday evening a visiting federal judge had temporarily blocked the Elections System from excluding candidates under the settlement rules, days before the May 19 deadline.

The 2026 election became official this week. Filing season opened Tuesday with the Democratic ticket of Delegate Stacey Plaskett and Senate President Milton Potter submitting nomination papers for governor and lieutenant governor, campaigning as "People Powered, Ready to Deliver." On Thursday, Lt. Gov. Tregenza Roach and Sen. Novelle E. Francis Jr. filed the second gubernatorial ticket, with Roach promising a grid drawing on multiple power sources "so that at no time would you have an entire island without power at the same time," and Francis pointing to responsive police and available ambulances as what voters actually ask about. Their formal campaign launch is planned for May 30.

Down the ballot, candidates filed in both districts for the Legislature, Board of Education, and Board of Elections, from Lorelei Monsanto, Carla Joseph, Angel Bolques Jr., and Dwayne DeGraff on St. Thomas to Franklin Johnson and Elizabeth Hansen Watley, daughter of the late Sen. Alicia "Chucky" Hansen, on St. Croix. The deadline for nomination papers is Tuesday, May 19 at 6 p.m.

Then the rules moved. On Thursday, visiting U.S. District Judge Timothy Savage partially granted a temporary restraining order in the suit brought by Delegate candidate Shelley Moorhead and legislative hopefuls Collister Fahie and Monsanto, temporarily blocking the Elections System from excluding candidates from primary ballots for failing requirements created by the April 23 settlement with the Democratic Party. Savage ordered all certification records and nomination papers preserved in their current state, and ordered petitions containing inactive-voter signatures preserved without rejection or disqualification.

"The distinction Judge Savage is drawing is between a party deciding who they endorse, which is absolutely their right, and a party deciding who gets on the government's ballot, which is a different matter entirely," Moorhead told the Source.

What is not being said: Candidates spent the week filing for a ballot whose rules were enjoined before the filing window closed. A judge ordering every certification record preserved in its current state is a judge who expects to need the evidence. The territory is now administering its election and litigating its election simultaneously, with the same office doing both, and the deadline arrives Tuesday either way.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: First Candidate Filings Signal Start of 2026 Election Races (May 12, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Roach, Francis File Nomination Papers for Governor-Lieutenant Governor Bid (May 14, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Judge Grants Temporary Injunction in Challenge to Primary Ballot Rules (May 15, 2026)

The contract to replace the power plants is signed. Substantial completion: 2030.

WAPA and the disaster recovery office signed with R-G Engineering/Javelin Gramercy to replace parts of the Harley plant and fully modernize Richmond, twelve days after Richmond's generation loss blacked out St. Croix. Temporary generation is promised before year's end.

The Water and Power Authority and the Office of Disaster Recovery signed a contract Tuesday with the R-G Engineering/Javelin Gramercy Ventures Joint Venture for the FEMA-funded replacement of the territory's power plants: portions of the Randolph Harley plant on St. Thomas, and a full modernization of the Richmond plant on St. Croix, whose generation loss blacked out the entire island twelve days earlier. "This is a transformative opportunity," WAPA CEO Karl Knight told the Source. "It completes the positioning of St. Thomas for the future and gives St. Croix the chance to rebuild and transform its plant."

The construction phase is expected to run about 48 months, with substantial completion anticipated in 2030. A large share of that timeline is permitting: Knight said new generation must clear extensive EPA air permitting and emissions review before entering service. The project includes temporary generation, battery storage, demolition of obsolete equipment, and permanent generation in both districts, with FEMA funding confirmed in October 2024.

The near-term relief is smaller and sooner. Four new standby units totaling 10 megawatts have been purchased for the St. Thomas-St. John district and are expected to arrive this year. WAPA is pursuing 15 to 25 megawatts of leased temporary generation for each district, targeted online before the end of the year, and roughly 10 megawatts of emergency generation for St. John between August and November. "We're trying to get temporary generation in before the end of this year," Knight said. "We have some pretty good offers."

The contractor, based in Puerto Rico, has worked WAPA's system before, including repairs tied to Units 27 and 15 at Harley, the unit whose failures drove this year's rotational outages. "They understand isolated grids and our situation in the Western Caribbean," Knight said.

What is not being said: Between this signature and substantial completion stand four hurricane seasons, an EPA permitting gauntlet, and every unit failure the existing plants have left in them. The promises with dates inside 2026, four standby units, leased temporary generation, ten megawatts for St. John by November, are the ones residents can actually hold the utility to, and this digest will track each one. 2030 is not a plan; it is a horizon. The year-end commitments are the plan.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: WAPA, ODR Sign Contract for Major Power Plant Replacement Project Across Territory (May 12, 2026)

The rebuild needs 5,500 workers housed, and the first concrete proposal died of neighborhood

A 450-bed workforce camp proposed for 14 acres in Estate Bakkero drew resident opposition, a DPNR denial recommendation, and senators quoting the oldest rule in the territory: temporary becomes permanent. No vote was taken.

The abstract question from April's disaster recovery hearing, where thousands of off-island construction workers will live, met its first concrete answer Monday, and the answer was a fight. Bill 36-0287 would rezone about 14 acres in Estate Bakkero, above the Frenchman's Reef corridor, from low-density residential to medium-density to allow a 450-bed workforce housing complex: 18 one-story buildings, 30 modular units, shared dining, laundry, and fitness facilities, potentially in place 10 to 15 years.

Developer Joseph Todd Donohoo of Sweetgrass Valley Properties told the Committee of the Whole the projects are already suffering: "Currently, these projects are delayed due to the lack of workforce housing," he testified, adding that none of the major contractors in the government rebuild have housing secured. He said he has no intention of keeping the units after recovery work ends and would support a removal requirement written into law.

The neighborhood answered with covenants and character. Residents called the proposal an industrial man camp inside a subdivision whose covenants have barred trailers since the 1970s. "Established residential communities should not become the default location for cost-saving workforce housing solutions, simply because doing so may be cheaper or more convenient," attorney Alia Felix-Blyden told senators. The Department of Planning and Natural Resources recommended denying the rezoning, saying the project could proceed instead through a Planned Area Development process, which residents in turn called a mechanism to accomplish indirectly what rezoning cannot justify directly.

Territorial planner Leia LaPlace-Matthew warned the dispute may be unresolvable in the chamber: "The zoning law cannot be used to abrogate or annul covenants. This may end up being a court matter." Senators leaned against the site while endorsing the need. "In the Virgin Islands, temporary becomes permanent," Sen. Kurt Vialet said, urging government land or existing facilities instead. Sen. Franklin Johnson was blunter: "I really can't support this. It just don't feel right." No votes were taken; the bill moves to a future session.

What is not being said: Everyone in the chamber agreed the territory needs worker housing, and no one would take this worker housing. That is a stable political equilibrium: each site's neighbors will make the same case Bakkero's made, and each will be right that somewhere else is better. What Monday did not produce, and what no agency has published, is the list of government-owned sites where a camp would be acceptable. Until that list exists, the 5,500-worker question will keep being answered one refusal at a time, on the recovery's clock.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Lawmakers Debate Over 450-Bed Workforce Camp Proposed for Estate Bakkero (May 11, 2026)

Two homicides in 24 hours, a hundred rounds in Frederiksted, and a Saturday killing to close the week

Kaleem Iles, 47, was shot dead Tuesday morning on St. Croix; Aubrey L. Frett, 66, died early Wednesday on St. Thomas, the territory's 11th homicide of the year by the Source's count. Police were investigating another fatal shooting in Estate Tutu on Saturday.

The week opened with Delegate Stacey Plaskett responding to a report of more than 100 gunshots fired in Frederiksted. "The ongoing violence in our territory weighs heavily on me," she said in a Sunday statement, calling Frederiksted a town that has endured years of neglect and deserves safety, investment, and the full attention of every level of government.

By Wednesday the violence had names. Kaleem Iles, 47, was shot dead Tuesday morning in the Mon Bijou area of St. Croix, where police responding to 911 calls and a ShotSpotter alert of numerous rounds at 8:17 a.m. found him with several gunshot wounds. Less than 24 hours later, officers were called to Haabets Gade near Simmonds Alley in downtown Charlotte Amalie at 12:38 a.m. Wednesday; Aubrey L. Frett, 66, died at Schneider Regional just after 4 a.m. His death was the fourth homicide of the year on St. Thomas and the 11th territory-wide, according to the Source Homicide List, and came ten days after Daniel Simpkins, 30, was killed in the Christiansted market area.

The week did not close quietly: police reported a fatal shooting in Estate Tutu on Saturday, under investigation as the weekend began.

In each case the appeal was the same: call 911, the VIPD, or the anonymous Crime Stoppers line. The Iles investigation, with the Criminal Investigation Bureau, had produced no announced arrest by week's end.

What is not being said: The only official statement the week produced came Sunday, about gunfire that hit no one, before either killing happened. Two men died in the days that followed, and the government's public response was tip-line boilerplate. The running count that put Frett at number 11 is maintained by a newspaper, not by any agency of the government whose residents are being killed. That a homicide ledger is volunteer work says as much as the number on it.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Plaskett Comments on St. Croix Shootings (May 10, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Man Shot Dead on St. Thomas in Second Homicide in 2 Days, VIPD Reports (May 13, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Police Investigate Fatal Shooting in Estate Tutu (May 16, 2026)

After 11 years, the Army Corps quietly permitted the Summers End marina

The permit for the 115-slip Coral Bay marina was issued April 20 and announced May 1 under a policy called Building Infrastructure Not Paperwork, reported Sunday. Save Coral Bay, whose 3,000-signature request for public hearings was denied, says the fight moves to territorial permits.

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has issued the federal permit the Summer's End Group has pursued for more than 11 years, clearing the way for a 115-slip marina in Coral Bay, St. John, with 12 additional moorings for a total of 127 vessels, a 67,833-square-foot fixed-dock footprint, a boardwalk, retail complex, and boutique hotel. The permit was issued April 20 and announced by the Corps May 1, and reported by the Source on Sunday, May 10.

The Corps framed the approval under its "Building Infrastructure Not Paperwork" initiative, aimed at faster permitting decisions. In April, opponents at Save Coral Bay had presented the Corps a petition with 3,000 signatures requesting public hearings; the request was denied.

The permit's conditions carry the environmental ledger: impacts to 2.39 acres of seagrass, offset by required restoration of 4.596 acres of mangrove-island complex and 0.975 acres of seagrass habitat, relocation of corals, outplanting of 3,000 coral specimens, 300 red mangrove seedlings, and monitoring under performance standards. Managing partner Chaliese Summers said the group will spend over $5.3 million on marine protection, put initial investment at $130 million, and claimed more than 80 long-term jobs for St. John. Demolition and debris removal, she said, have already begun.

Save Coral Bay president David Silverman disputes the foundation: the project, he argues, has changed dramatically since the decade-old approvals the permit relies on, and its mitigation plan requires at least 20,000 cubic yards of fill in Coral Harbor, which he says contradicts the 2014 Water Quality Certificate barring dredge or fill activity. Territorial authorizations, for submerged trust lands, fill, and shoreline excavation among others, are not yet in place. "This is actually just the beginning of a new chapter," Silverman said.

What is not being said: Three thousand people asked for a public hearing and the answer was a policy whose name announces its priorities: Building Infrastructure Not Paperwork. The hearing they were denied is where the central dispute, whether this is still the project approved a decade ago, would have been aired on the record. Instead that question will be litigated permit by permit in territorial agencies, where the project has stalled before, and the public's participation was reduced to a petition that received a form denial.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Army Corps Approves Permit for Summers End Marina in Coral Bay (May 10, 2026)

The ferry-rate investigation is now a fight about the investigator's bill

The examiner's initial findings say ferry companies are compensated for boats gone a decade and ridership no one can verify. The companies say his eight days of April work cost them $80,000. The fuel-surcharge question was tabled to June.

The Public Services Commission's investigation of St. Thomas-St. John ferry rates turned Tuesday into a dispute over what the investigating costs. Attorney Maria Tankenson Hodge, representing Varlack Ventures and Transportation Services of St. John, told commissioners that hearing examiner Jed JohnHope billed the two family companies roughly $80,000 for eight days of work in April at $400 an hour, plus travel she called excessive, including a hotel room of about $800. The PSC tabled its vote on collecting assessment costs and referred the billing dispute to its executive director.

JohnHope, who contacted the Source after publication to note he was given no opportunity to respond on the record at the meeting, said the statements included inaccuracies: he rented no car, the lodging was pre-approved through PSC channels after a hearing day that ran from about 7 a.m. to 10 p.m., and the roughly $710-before-tax room rate is not uncommon on St. John in peak season.

Buried under the billing fight are the examiner's actual findings so far, which are considerably harder on the companies. JohnHope's initial recommendations: deny any rate increase. "There are boats that have been outside of the territory for almost 10 years that are being compensated for," he told the commission. "There are boats that have been retired. They're being compensated for." He called it nonsensical that the companies jointly own the ticketing apparatus, making ridership and revenue impossible to verify, and recommended audits of payroll, fuel, and vessel disposition. PSC Chair David Hughes told the operators plainly: "You're being overcompensated."

The companies also petitioned for an emergency $0.75 fuel surcharge, citing fuel costs driven by the war with Iran and the closure of the Strait of Hormuz. Commissioners tabled it to June. Public Works Commissioner Derek Gabriel separately said he supports a fuel surcharge structured to fall on non-residents, and the examiner's final report neared completion with a last hearing set for Thursday.

What is not being said: The finding that ferry companies have been compensated for boats that left the territory a decade ago, under a rate structure the Legislature itself built, arrived the same day as the fight over an $800 hotel room, and the hotel room got the oxygen. The St. John commuter who pays these rates should notice which of those two numbers is being investigated with more energy. The surcharge decision waits for June; the fuel bills do not.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Ferry Operators Raise Alarm About Rate Investigator, Rising Fuel Prices (May 12, 2026), St. Thomas Source: DPW Commissioner Gabriel Clarifies Ferry Routes; Supports Fuel Surcharge for Non-Residents (May 13, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Final Ferry Rate Hearing Set for Thursday as Examiner Defends Findings, Oversight Costs (May 13, 2026)

A Tootsys defendant won conditional release as the indictment landed

U.S. Magistrate G. Alan Teague granted Magda Castro Santos pretrial release on an unsecured $50,000 bond with strict conditions: ankle monitor, no contact with alleged victims including her wife, banned from Red Hook and Bolongo, employment outside any club or bar. She stays jailed pending vetting of her custodian and home. Teague said an indictment has been handed down, starting the 70-day speedy trial clock, with arraignment set for Wednesday. Hussein Jamil remains denied bail. (St. Thomas Source)

NTSB asked the public for what witnesses have been afraid to give

Federal investigators formally sought witnesses, photos, and video of the May 2 collision that killed Shawn Leass, promising names would be redacted in NTSB documents, an answer to the reluctance witnesses described to the Source, some fearing reprisal from federal law enforcement. Divers recovered the sunken dinghy May 7 after an all-day search. VI Update's related records requests, including one to Delegate Plaskett's office seeking an inquiry letter, are logged in this edition's tracker. (St. Thomas Source)

The territory's opioid settlement total reached $1.59 million

AG Gordon Rhea announced the $7.4 billion Purdue Pharma/Sackler settlement is legally effective, bringing the territory's secured opioid settlement funds to $1,586,934.33, with funds designated for prevention, treatment, and recovery. The Sacklers are permanently barred from selling opioids in the U.S., and more than 30 million internal documents will become public. (St. Thomas Source)

Cannabis is "right on the cusp" of legal cultivation

The Cannabis Advisory Board approved laboratory testing standards for contaminants, heavy metals, and product types, standards its regulator called deliberately stringent given the islands' humidity and St. Croix's industrial soil history. Nine practitioners and 44 patients are active in the medical program, several commercial cultivators await final inspection, and unsuccessful dispensary applicants get a one-time 30-day amendment window. (St. Thomas Source)

CZM approved 12 more Botany Bay rooms and rejected a St. Croix tower

The Coastal Zone Management Commission approved 12 additional rooms at the Botany Bay resort while tightening enforcement of the 75-foot shoreline setback, and separately rejected a proposed communications tower on St. Croix. (St. Thomas Source)

UVI graduated its 62nd class on both islands

A week after warning senators its free-tuition program could be suspended, the university celebrated its 62nd commencement on St. Thomas and St. Croix, with messages of pride and perseverance for the class of 2026. (St. Thomas Source)

Pedro "Pete" Encarnacion, former senator, was remembered

Tributes gathered for former Sen. Pedro "Pete" Encarnacion, remembered for a lifetime of service, music, and community connection, the second former senator the territory lost this month. (St. Thomas Source)