Good Day, This Week — No. 013, May 17–23, 2026
An automated news digest and analysis, operated by Brian Louden. VI Update.
Nine tickets for Government House: the deadline locked in the territory's most crowded race in years
Tuesday's 6 p.m. filing deadline closed with three Democratic and six independent gubernatorial tickets, ten candidates for Delegate, and 57 legislative hopefuls, including the ferry-rate examiner, a constitutional delegate running on recovery oversight, and a Senate hopeful the attorney general had just ruled ineligible for the Senate.
The 2026 field is set. When nomination papers closed Tuesday at 6 p.m., nine tickets had filed for governor and lieutenant governor: Democrats Stacey Plaskett and Milton Potter, Donna Frett-Gregory and Rodney Moorehead, and Tregenza Roach and Novelle Francis Jr., alongside six independent tickets including Adlah "Foncie" Donastorg and Positive Nelson, Oakland Benta and Merwin Potter, and economist Warren Mosler with Colin Robertson. Frett-Gregory filed Tuesday afternoon, framing her campaign in one word repeated three ways: "This campaign is about delivering results. This campaign is about listening to our people. It's about execution."
The Delegate to Congress race drew ten candidates: Democrats Delia Smith, Janelle Sarauw, Emmett Hansen, Teri Helenese, and Antonio Emanuel, and independents including Shelley Moorhead, James Weber III, Ida Smith Alexander, Brett "Mac" McClafferty, and Jed JohnHope, the hearing examiner whose ferry-rate findings roiled the PSC this month. Fifty-seven candidates filed for the Legislature, 29 in St. Thomas-St. John and 28 on St. Croix, plus crowded Board of Education and Board of Elections fields.
McClafferty's filing came with an asterisk the size of a legal opinion. On Monday, Attorney General Gordon Rhea formally concluded McClafferty is ineligible for the Legislature under Section 6(b) of the Revised Organic Act, citing Ohio felony convictions between 2015 and 2019 involving passing bad checks, forgery, identity fraud, cocaine possession, and grand theft, crimes the seven-page opinion classifies as involving moral turpitude, and noting "McClafferty does not have a pardon." The opinion rejected his attorney's arguments that the convictions were reversed or that Ohio's restoration of civil rights suffices. It does not, itself, remove anyone from a ballot.
By the time the opinion landed, McClafferty had pivoted to the Delegate race, whose qualifications are governed by federal law rather than the Revised Organic Act, a distinction the Source noted raises a separate legal question no one has yet answered. The same day, he filed an emergency motion to travel to St. Croix to view a possible campaign headquarters, and asked the court to loosen his release conditions in his pending fraud case so he can campaign between districts. Among those filing for Senate: constitutional delegate Imani Daniel, running with a coalition platform focused on oversight of the remaining federal recovery billions: "If we give any of it back, that's a loss for all of us."
What is not being said: A candidate ruled ineligible for one office on Monday was a candidate for a higher office by Tuesday, and the machinery that processed his filing has no announced answer to whether the federal qualifications for Delegate reach his record. The attorney general's opinion is not a court ruling, ballot challenges have deadlines, and the primary calendar is already in federal litigation. Someone will have to decide this on the record, soon, or voters will decide it without knowing it was ever a question.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Filing Deadline Locks In Crowded 2026 Election Field (May 19, 2026), St. Thomas Source: AG Opinion Closes Door on McClafferty's Senate Bid, but Delegate Run Raises Different Legal Question (May 18, 2026), St. Thomas Source: McClafferty Seeks Bail Modification So He Can Campaign for Delegate (May 18, 2026)
The Tootsys indictment reads like a business plan, and the business was debt
The trio pleaded not guilty Wednesday and got a July 13 trial date. The 15-page indictment spans June 2019 to 2026: recruiting by Instagram, smuggling fees paid in sex, nightly buy-ins, $500 fines for missed nights, and a January undercover operation.
Hussein Jamil, Magda Castro Santos, and Julio Hidalgo de Pena pleaded not guilty Wednesday at their arraignment in federal court on St. Thomas, and U.S. Magistrate Judge G. Alan Teague set trial for July 13 before Chief Judge Robert Molloy. All three remain jailed while custodian and housing arrangements for conditional release are sorted; Jamil's attorneys have moved for reconsideration of his detention, proposing his brother and sister-in-law as custodians.
The 15-page indictment handed down May 13 covers June 2019 through 2026 and describes an operation whose product, prosecutors allege, was debt. Dancers recruited from the mainland, Latin America, and the Caribbean were charged $100 to $200 a week to live at Bolongo 25, despite advertising promising free housing, paid a $40 to $60 buy-in every night simply to work, and owed $500 for every night missed. Women smuggled in through the British Virgin Islands allegedly incurred smuggling fees to Jamil, which the indictment says some paid off by having sex with him.
The recruiting pitch is quoted verbatim from a December 2019 Instagram message: the club would pay airfare, provide housing and transportation, and the message itemized the economics down to the champagne room split. The indictment alleges Castro Santos collected the fees and pressured dancers toward commercial sex, photographing customer IDs for Jamil's approval on "buyouts," while Hidalgo de Pena drove the women between Bolongo 25 and the club. In one January undercover operation, prosecutors say, Castro Santos processed a $575 credit card transaction for an officer to take a dancer off site, then arranged the taxi to the hotel.
The charges, conspiracy to transport for prostitution, conspiracy to commit interstate and foreign travel in aid of racketeering enterprises, and conspiracy to harbor aliens for financial gain, carry up to 10 years each. All of it remains allegation; none of the three has been convicted, and their attorneys have argued the government's evidence fails to connect them to criminal activity. A pretrial conference is set for June 24.
What is not being said: The indictment names Co-Conspirator 1, who ran his own club and loaned a smuggled woman to Jamil, and a co-conspirator unknown to the grand jury who moved another woman through St. John. It describes a smuggling route through the BVI that operated for years. None of those people are charged in this indictment, and the corrupt-officials allegation from the April detention filing appears nowhere in it. The trial will try three people. The network the indictment sketches is larger than three people.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Tootsys Trio Plead Not Guilty at Arraignment; Trial Set for July (May 20, 2026)
The cargo ships that stock the shelves can go back to San Juan, if the paperwork holds
The Coast Guard barred the Water Spirit 2 and Admiral Pride from San Juan over their mooring in the San Antonio Channel. After a Monday meeting push from Bryan, the path back is a marine survey and a new docking plan.
The two cargo ships that haul food, vehicles, appliances, and construction materials between San Juan and the Virgin Islands can return to Puerto Rico once they satisfy the Coast Guard with a new mooring plan, Gov. Albert Bryan Jr. said Thursday. The 210-foot Water Spirit 2 and 205-foot Admiral Pride were warned, then fined, after partially obstructing the narrow San Antonio Channel on May 1; Coast Guard photos show the Water Spirit 2 stern-first against a wharf with bow chains extending into the channel.
The April 30 Captain of the Port orders, reported in the territory on May 16, directed the vessels to stop their Mediterranean-style mooring operations at Pier 10, a practice Bryan said began only after their regular docking area was moved. "The issue at hand is strictly related to the location being used for loading and off-loading operations following changes at the marina facility," he said.
Bryan announced Monday he would meet with Coast Guard officials, asking for a temporary variance to keep the ships running while a permanent fix was worked out. "This route moves food, refrigerated goods, vehicles, appliances, construction materials, industrial parts and household items that our residents and businesses rely on," he said. The variance did not materialize, but the path back did: both companies were retaining a marine surveyor to produce the documentation the Coast Guard requires. "Once the survey is completed and accepted by the Coast Guard, the vessels should be able to resume shipments and regular service to Puerto Rico," Bryan said, adding that if agreement stalls, the government will work with the operators, the Puerto Rico Ports Authority, and the Coast Guard to find an alternative dock.
What is not being said: Two ships lost their dock in a marina reshuffle, improvised a mooring, and got banned for it, and for three weeks the supply line for groceries and building materials between Puerto Rico and four islands ran on improvisation and goodwill. The episode ended tolerably, but it mapped a fragility: the territory's freight depends on two aging vessels, one pier assignment in another jurisdiction's harbor, and nobody's contingency plan. The month Spirit Airlines vanished overnight was a strange month to learn the sea link is nearly as thin.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Bryan Announces Meeting with Coast Guard Regarding Recent Ban on VI Cargo Ships (May 18, 2026), St. Thomas Source: V.I. Cargo Ships Can Return to San Juan With New Docking Plan (May 21, 2026)
The territory's next federal judge was confirmed 52-47, without a single Democratic vote
Evan Rikhye, Walmart senior counsel and twice a federal prosecutor on St. Croix, will fill Judge Wilma Lewis's seat on the District Court after a party-line Senate vote and a confirmation process Democrats called an insult.
The U.S. Senate confirmed Evan Rikhye to the District Court of the Virgin Islands on Wednesday, 52-47, along party lines. Rikhye, currently senior counsel for Walmart in Bentonville, Arkansas, served as an assistant U.S. attorney on St. Croix from 2008 to 2011 and again from 2021 to 2024, working prosecutions including the Casino Control Commission fraud case and the Charlemagne HUD fraud indictment. He fills the seat of Judge Wilma Lewis, on senior status since February 2025, for a 10-year term.
President Trump announced the nomination in February on Truth Social: "He will make an even better Judge!" The confirmation process was less celebratory. Asked in written questions from Sen. Dick Durbin whether Trump lost the 2020 election, Rikhye answered that President Biden "was certified as the winner of the 2020 election, and he served a 4-year term." Asked about pardons for January 6 rioters convicted of assaulting police, and about the president's characterizations of federal judges as monsters, he declined each time, citing the Code of Conduct for United States Judges.
Sen. Richard Blumenthal called the answers "obviously canned, pre-rehearsed, Orwellian in their denial of reality," and "an insult to this committee." No swearing-in date has been announced.
The seat matters locally in concrete ways: the District Court is where the territory's federal criminal docket, its election litigation, and its consent decrees live. The court that will try the Tootsys case, hear the ballot-access suits, and oversee the jail monitor now has a full complement again.
What is not being said: Virgin Islanders had no senator voting on the judge who will preside over their federal cases for the next decade, which is the standing arithmetic of territorial status: the bench is chosen entirely by people no resident here elected. A nominee's careful refusals tell you little about how he will rule; his docket will. This digest will be reading it.
A record sargassum year meets a below-normal hurricane forecast
DPNR says every region set April sargassum records and the territory should brace for its worst accumulation year, while NOAA's outlook gives the Atlantic a 55 percent chance of a below-normal season as El Niño builds. Officials on both subjects said the same word: prepare.
The territory got its two big seasonal forecasts the same week, pointed in opposite directions. The Department of Planning and Natural Resources warned that 2026 is predicted to be a record-high year for sargassum accumulation on the territory's beaches, citing the University of South Florida Optical Oceanography Lab's April 30 report that nearly every Atlantic region set a record for the month. Commissioner Jean-Pierre Oriol's guidance was blunt: decomposing sargassum releases hydrogen sulfide, and "avoiding beaches with large amounts of decaying sargassum is the best method of prevention." Beachfront businesses can seek authorization for mechanical removal; containment booms need an Army Corps permit. Separately, DPNR warned that trash tangled in drying sargassum mats could become a fire hazard.
The hurricane outlook leans kinder. NOAA forecasts a below-normal 2026 Atlantic season: a 55 percent chance of below-normal activity, 8 to 14 named storms, 3 to 6 hurricanes, 1 to 3 major, driven by an El Niño given a 98 percent chance of developing, with 80 percent odds it reaches moderate to strong. El Niño's wind shear tears Atlantic storms apart, and pushes activity toward the Pacific instead.
Every official on the call then spent their time arguing against their own forecast's comfort. "It only takes one storm," NOAA Administrator Neil Jacobs said, noting Category 5 landfalls have happened in below-average seasons. "There's no such thing as 'just' a Tropical Storm," National Weather Service Director Ken Graham added, pointing to storms that were tropical storms days before major landfall. This year's forecast cone graphics will for the first time include inland watches and warnings for the U.S. Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico.
The territory's own rehearsal happened Thursday, when WAPA, VITEMA, and the Energy Office conducted a joint preparedness exercise ahead of the June 1 season start.
What is not being said: A below-normal season forecast is the most dangerous kind for a territory whose grid fails on sunny days. The relevant question for the Virgin Islands is not how many storms form in the Atlantic; it is how many hours of Category 1 winds the current Richmond and Harley plants, the temporary generators still on order, and a St. John fed by one submarine cable could survive. Nobody forecasts that number publicly. El Niño does not repair transmission lines.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Record High Sargassum Predicted (May 19, 2026), St. Thomas Source: NOAA Outlook Calls for Below-Normal Atlantic Hurricane Season, But Preparedness Remains Critical (May 21, 2026), St. Thomas Source: WAPA, VITEMA, and VIEO Conduct Preparedness Exercise (May 21, 2026)
St. Croix went dark again Saturday, and this time the instruments saw the whole thing
VI Update's polling of WAPA's feed recorded 25,109 St. Croix customers out at 1:57 p.m. Saturday, effectively the whole island, the third island-wide St. Croix outage in a month. The week also brought $9.4 million in EPA water funding.
The week closed with St. Croix dark again. VI Update's polling of WAPA's public outage feed recorded the territory's weekly peak at 1:57 p.m. Saturday, May 23: 25,256 customers without power, of which 25,109 were on St. Croix, effectively the island's entire customer base. It was the third time in a month, after April 25 and April 30, that St. Croix lost power island-wide. As of week's end, no press account of Saturday's outage had been published; the feed data is the record.
The failures come with the replacement plan now under contract but years out: the Richmond plant's modernization, signed May 12, anticipates substantial completion in 2030, with leased temporary generation promised before the end of this year. Saturday's numbers are the baseline those promises will be measured against.
The week's water news ran the other direction. The EPA announced $9.4 million for the territory to test for and mitigate PFAS, the so-called forever chemicals linked to cancer, in drinking water, the territory's third allotment under the Emerging Contaminants program for small and disadvantaged communities. The announcement came a day after the EPA unveiled a new PFAS strategy that some environmentalists describe as a rollback of the 2024 limits; EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin cast it as replacing standards water systems could not implement.
Also in the pipes: WAPA planned water line rehabilitation for the Blackbeard Hill area on St. Thomas, and scheduled two St. Croix electrical interruptions for maintenance work.
What is not being said: Three island-wide outages in twenty-nine days is no longer a streak of bad luck; it is the operating condition of St. Croix's grid. The Saturday failure produced no press release and no news story by week's end, which is what normalization looks like: the island going entirely dark has stopped being an event. The only contemporaneous public record is a polling script. That is why the polling script exists.
Sources: VI Update outage dashboard (WAPA public feed, polled every five minutes), St. Thomas Source: EPA Earmarks $9.4 Million for USVI Drinking Water (May 19, 2026), St. Thomas Source: WAPA Schedules Two St. Croix Electrical Interruptions (May 15, 2026)
A constitutional scholar told the Sixth Convention its draft is more ambitious than any state constitution
University of Texas professor Richard Albert delivered a detailed review of the Sixth Constitutional Convention's draft at a Saturday plenary, urging simpler language and warning that provisions sit "a little uneasily with the requirements of federal supremacy," which he reminded delegates "is not optional." He also cautioned that the draft's ambition carries higher litigation risk than the average state constitution. (St. Thomas Source)
VIPA's board ratified the racetrack deal and aired a fight over poll votes
The Port Authority board ratified the government's use of the Randall "Doc" James Racetrack property and extended the Sky City P3 transition agreement through December 31, over board member Celestino White's objection that poll votes lock in decisions "with whatever little information you may have at the time." The board also authorized a new St. Thomas-St. John diesel contract and leases, and said the Cyril E. King runway resurfacing contract runs to February 2027 but is still intended to finish this year. (St. Thomas Source)
A minor was found competent to stand trial in the Dutty Heart case
A Superior Court judge found the minor defendant competent to stand trial in the Dutty Heart homicide case, a week after the defense moved to dismiss the first-degree murder charges. (St. Thomas Source)
A man surrendered in the Frederiksted shooting case
A man surrendered to police in connection with a Frederiksted shooting, in the town where more than 100 rounds fired two weeks earlier drew a statement from the delegate. (St. Thomas Source)
Flags at half staff for Pete Encarnacion; Memorial Day ceremonies set
Gov. Bryan ordered flags to half staff for former Sen. Pedro "Pete" Encarnacion, and veterans' graves across the territory received new flags ahead of Monday's Memorial Day ceremonies. (St. Thomas Source)
Feds pitch an app for the airport lines
Federal officials said an expanded CBP pre-departure app should ease waits at the territory's airports, where departing travelers clear customs before boarding. (St. Thomas Source)