Good Day, This Week — No. 014, May 24–30, 2026

An automated news digest and analysis, operated by Brian Louden. VI Update.

Disqualifications, a dismissal, and a drawing of lots: the ballot took its real shape this week

The Elections System knocked several candidates off for defective filings, a federal judge dismissed two of the three ballot-access suits for lack of standing, and Friday's casting of lots set the August 1 primary order, with Roach-Francis drawing first position.

The crowded field from filing week met the fine print. Supervisor of Elections Caroline Fawkes said several aspirants have been disqualified: Delegate candidate Jed JohnHope fell short of the requirement for 100 qualified electors' signatures from each of two districts; former Sen. James Weber III filed in the wrong district; and two gubernatorial tickets collapsed at the running-mate line, one when Horris Graham formally stated he had never agreed to run with Roy Sheridan, another when Stephen "Smokey" Frett's running mate turned out not to be a registered voter. "Anything can be challenged," Fawkes said of the rejections. A later disqualification took out St. Croix legislative candidate Jaylen Gabriel for insufficient signatures.

The courtroom track thinned too. U.S. District Judge Timothy Savage on Tuesday dismissed two of the three suits brought by Shelley Moorhead, Collister Fahie, and Lorelei Monsanto, including the one in which he had granted a temporary injunction two weeks earlier, ruling the candidates' claimed injuries were "merely possible" rather than actual or imminent and that they lacked standing. If Moorhead's petition fails over inactive-voter signatures, Savage wrote, "it will be due to his own failure to ascertain which electors' signatures are valid." A third suit, over whether parties may effectively control ballot access through certification, remains active; the Democratic Party's attorney called the litigation "nothing more than a publicity stunt."

By Friday evening the surviving field was drawing numbered lots on St. Croix. In the governor's race, Tregenza Roach and Novelle Francis Jr. drew first ballot position, Stacey Plaskett and Milton Potter second, Donna Frett-Gregory and Rodney Moorehead third. Emmett Hansen drew first in the Delegate race, ahead of Delia Smith, Teri Helenese, and Janelle Sarauw. The primary is August 1.

Fawkes's practical instructions matter as much as the ballot order: voter registration closes July 2, absentee applications open June 2, and inactive voters should re-activate. "If you're inactive, become active," she said.

What is not being said: The injunction that made headlines two weeks ago dissolved on standing, which means the underlying question, whether a private party may sit between a candidate and the government's ballot, was never actually decided. It survives in the one remaining suit. Meanwhile the office defending that litigation exercised its disqualification power all week, probably correctly in each case, but reviewed by no one unless someone pays to challenge it. The election's referee keeps making calls in a game where the rulebook is still in court.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Candidate Disqualifications Narrow 2026 Field as Elections Review Continues (May 26, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Election Lawsuits Dismissed by Judge (May 27, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Democratic Primary Ballot Orders Announced After Casting of Lots (May 29, 2026)

Rotating outages on Memorial Day, and a Saturday night that took down most of St. Thomas

WAPA published a holiday load-shedding schedule at 9:30 a.m. on Memorial Day itself. The week ended worse: at 9:57 p.m. Saturday the feed showed 31,961 customers out, 24,891 of them on St. Thomas, with no public account by week's end.

Memorial Day on St. Thomas and St. John came with a schedule of darkness. Citing reduced generation capacity, WAPA published a rotating outage plan in a press release issued just after 9:30 a.m. on the holiday itself, feeder by feeder, two-hour blocks from 10 a.m. to midnight, subject to change based on demand. Residents learned whether their barbecue would have power by looking up their feeder.

The Cancryn wastewater pump failed again Tuesday, the second failure in two weeks at the station whose bypass repair was completed in April, keeping the Waste Management Authority's sewer emergency simmering under the utility week.

Then came Saturday night. At 9:57 p.m. on May 30, VI Update's polling of WAPA's public feed recorded 31,961 customers without power, the worst moment of the year to date in this tracker: 24,891 on St. Thomas, 7,066 on St. Croix, with 43 separate outages open. That is most of the St. Thomas district dark at once, on the last night of the week. As of this edition, no WAPA statement or press account of the Saturday night event had been published; the feed archive is the record.

The failures bracket a week that began with the utility's own holiday admission of inadequate generation and ended with the hurricane season two days away. The temporary generation WAPA has promised before year's end, and the roughly 10 megawatts of emergency generation for St. John due between August and November, are the commitments this pattern will test.

What is not being said: Three of the last four weeks have now ended with an island mostly dark on a Saturday, twice on St. Croix, now St. Thomas, and none of the three events produced a same-week public accounting from the utility. A load-shedding schedule published at 9:30 on the morning of the holiday it governs is not communication; it is documentation of a decision already made. Hurricane season starts Monday. The grid's condition is not a secret, but it is increasingly something residents learn from instruments rather than from the institution they pay.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: WAPA Announces Rotating Outages for STT-STJ District on Memorial Day (May 25, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Cancryn Wastewater Pump Fails (May 26, 2026), VI Update outage dashboard (WAPA public feed, polled every five minutes)

For the first time, the Supreme Court of the Virgin Islands has all five seats filled

The Legislature confirmed Denise M. Francois to a 10-year term as the court's fifth justice, only its second woman, and Renee M. Andre to six years on the Superior Court bench in St. Thomas-St. John.

The 36th Legislature on Thursday confirmed Associate Justice Denise M. Francois to a 10-year term on the Supreme Court of the Virgin Islands and attorney Renee M. Andre to a six-year term on the Superior Court in the St. Thomas-St. John district. Chief Justice Rhys Hodge called Francois's confirmation "a monumental milestone": the first time the court will seat all five justices since Act 7888 expanded it from three, and only the second woman appointed to the territory's highest court.

Francois's path ran through nearly every branch of Virgin Islands legal life: investigator in the Division of Paternity and Child Support, economist at the Commerce Department, then almost 30 years of practice, including as partner in Hodge and Francois, before Gov. deJongh put her on the Superior Court in 2013. She has served there since, most recently as administrative judge for the district, carrying a caseload that stood at 356 matters when senators reviewed her nomination in April.

Andre, a Charlotte Amalie High School graduate who clerked for District Judge Curtis Gomez and spent 18 years in practice with the Law Offices of Marjorie Rawls Roberts, joins a bench whose confirmation hearing was dominated by one subject: delay. She told senators then that she would manage cases with firm scheduling and scrutiny of continuances. Presiding Judge Jessica Gallivan said the judiciary is confident she "will serve with integrity and distinction."

What is not being said: The hearing that advanced both nominees was about backlog, and the confirmation announcement does not say who inherits the 356 cases Francois leaves behind on the Superior Court, or how long her seat there sits empty. Elevating a judge does not decide a single one of the cases waiting below her; it moves the queue to someone else's name. The full Supreme Court is a genuine milestone. The trial-court arithmetic is where litigants actually live.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Legislature Confirms Francois to Supreme Court, Andre to Superior Court Bench (May 28, 2026)

The Third Circuit found errors in the Girard-Harry trial and upheld the convictions anyway

The appeals court said the District Court mishandled courtroom access during the COVID-era gang trial and that prosecutors' witness procedures were imperfect, but ruled none of it was preserved well enough to matter. Life sentences stand.

The U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday upheld the convictions of Paul Girard and Kareem Harry, both 38, found guilty in 2022 of racketeering conspiracy, murder, kidnapping, and firearms crimes at the head of an organization prosecutors said terrorized the territory for nearly a decade. Harry is serving life plus 20 years; Girard, life plus 47. Seven others were convicted in the same conspiracy.

The appeal turned on the pandemic. The 2021 trial began with all spectators barred from the courtroom in favor of a video overflow room, and even after limited seating was allowed, the defendants' mothers were kept out by federal marshals for most of the trial, for reasons the record never explains. The appeals court agreed the District Court erred in how it balanced public-trial rights against COVID safety, and separately said it would have preferred that two co-defendants invoke the Fifth Amendment question by question rather than by blanket declaration.

None of it produced a new trial. The defense, the court found, never objected squarely at the time: "Parties must present arguments 'squarely,' so the district court has a chance to resolve them in the first instance." The first-day closure "was not designed for secrecy," the judges wrote, but was a good-faith pandemic measure, erroneous "only because the Court neglected to consider an alternative," and the cost of retrying both men would be significant.

Girard, known as Bogus, is held at the federal supermax in Florence, Colorado; Harry, known as Crumbull, at the high-security penitentiary in Coleman, Florida.

What is not being said: The opinion concedes two errors and remedies neither, because no lawyer said the right words at the right moment. That is how appellate law works, and it cuts in every direction: the same preservation rules that kept these convictions intact will one day keep an innocent defendant's error intact too. Two mothers were barred from a public trial by marshals for reasons no court has ever explained on the record, and after five years of litigation, the explanation still does not exist.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Appeal Denied: Gangsters' Convictions Stand (May 27, 2026)

The 80 homes above Magens Bay are down to permits and procurement

The Residences at 340 North cleared its environmental review and HUD comment period, confirmed $7.5 million for its first 22 affordable units, and put contractors on the clock, aiming to move dirt before hurricane season peaks.

The territory's most watched homegrown housing project moved from paperwork toward ground this week. The Residences at 340 North, an 80-unit development in Estate St. Joseph and Rosendahl overlooking Magens Bay, 64 townhomes and 16 single-family houses aimed at middle-income and first-time buyers, has completed its environmental review period, cleared HUD public comment, and confirmed approximately $7.5 million in Community Development Block Grant funding for its first 22 affordable units, which will carry income qualifications under federal guidelines.

The team at St. Thomas-based A.C. Development, led by civil engineer Ajani Corneiro, has pitched the project as "by Virgin Islanders, for Virgin Islanders," and its construction method as a first: Insulated Concrete Form construction at a scale the developers say the Caribbean has not seen, built for storm durability and lower energy costs. Corneiro estimates the first phase could generate more than $16 million in construction-related economic activity over an 18-to-24-month build.

The procurement clock is now running: contractor qualification requests went out May 15, a mandatory pre-proposal conference was set for Friday, and qualifications are due June 14 through the Housing Finance Authority's Ion Wave platform. Corneiro said the aim is to stabilize the site before the height of hurricane season: "If we're moving dirt in the high point of hurricane season, that's not a good spot we want to be in."

The context makes the project's 80 units count double: they arrive in a market where the government's own recovery office calls workforce housing a structural challenge, and where the only large housing proposal to reach the Legislature this month was a worker camp the neighborhood refused.

What is not being said: The affordable share of this project is 22 units of 80, and those 22 are the ones federal money and income limits attach to; the economics of the other 58 will decide who actually lives above Magens Bay. The developers' slogan will be tested in procurement, on a platform where local contractors either win work or watch it. Both numbers, the 22 and the winners' list, are checkable later, and worth checking.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Financing, Procurement Progress Pushes Residences at 340 North Closer to Construction (May 25, 2026)

The EDC tied four companies' tax breaks to jobs, youth money, and interns

The Economic Development Commission approved amendments requiring Historic Heritage Holdings to reach 25 full-time employees across its St. Croix hotel and financial-services operation, Neltjeberg Bay Enterprises to give $50,000 a year to youth charities with at least 55 percent to public schools, Saint Thomas Family Partners to make a verifiable $100,000 investment, and Virgin Islands Coffee Roasters to fund at least one paid local internship annually. (St. Thomas Source)

Memorial Day was observed on all three islands

Ceremonies honored fallen service members on St. Thomas, St. Croix, and in Cruz Bay, where the observance came with lessons, declarations, and doves, and veterans' graves carried new flags placed the weekend before. Gov. Bryan's message: "For we are grateful." (St. Thomas Source)

The forts' futures go to town halls

Town halls were announced to discuss the future of the Fort Christian and Fort Frederik museums, the territory's two most prominent historic structures. (St. Thomas Source)

Bryan called a St. Croix horse-racing stakeholder meeting

A month after announcing the $25 million Southland agreement for the Randall "Doc" James Race Track, Gov. Bryan called a stakeholder meeting on St. Croix racing's next steps. (St. Thomas Source)

La Vaughn Belle is a finalist for the Billie Holiday monument in Queens

The St. Croix artist, whose work confronts colonial monuments, was named a finalist to create a Billie Holiday monument in Queens, New York. (St. Thomas Source)

The billboard fight got its sequel

As public comment closed on the proposed LED billboard on Rhymer Highway, the Source examined why billboards, once up, rarely come down. (St. Thomas Source)