Good Day, This Week — No. 016, June 7–13, 2026
An automated news digest and analysis, operated by Brian Louden. VI Update.
Ten years for Martinez, seven for O'Neal, 22 months for the man who bribed them both
The corruption case that began with a $1.5 million ARPA police contract ended its sentencing week with a visiting judge's verdict on more than the defendants: corruption case after corruption case, and people telling him that is how business is done in the territory.
Former Police Commissioner Ray Martinez was sentenced Tuesday to 10 years in federal prison, former Management and Budget Director Jenifer O'Neal to seven years on Thursday, and David Whitaker, the contractor whose bribes and inflated invoices powered the scheme, to 22 months on Wednesday, closing the sentencing week for the kickback conspiracy built on a nearly $1.5 million VIPD surveillance contract funded by federal pandemic relief.
Judge Mark Kearney gave Martinez far less than the guidelines' 292-to-365-month range, crediting his decades of service and health history, but rejected the portrait of a bystander: recorded conversations showed Martinez knew exactly what he was doing, and his obstruction, destroying records and forging documents after the FBI came, was done in ways "only a police commissioner would know." Prosecutors noted he transferred his restaurant to family members after conviction; his wife, a VIPD lieutenant, withdrew her character testimony after the judge pressed the family's financial transparency. Martinez, who spoke for 45 minutes, forfeits $127,000, the approximate value of the gifts, plus more than $77,000 in restitution.
O'Neal's hearing carried the plainest evidence of intent. "I don't like traces of anything," she said in one recorded call about the $17,730 lease payment for her coffee shop; "'Wire' means it's traced." Shown luxury goods by Whitaker in a text, she circled a pair of Louboutin shoes, gave her size, and said "Or just the bag is fine." Kearney's summary: the one person who could get Whitaker and Martinez paid "was bought off for a lease payment and a pair of shoes." Her sentencing memo, filed a week late after open friction with her own attorney, claimed actual innocence and drew 29 support letters, including from sitting commissioners Derek Gabriel and Jean-Pierre Oriol. She reports to prison June 23.
Kearney, a visiting judge from Pennsylvania, closed with the observation that will outlast the docket: "And yet, we face corruption case after corruption case," he said, noting people have told him that is how business is done in the territory. "Well, in the United States, that's not how we do business."
What is not being said: Two sitting commissioners wrote character letters for a colleague convicted of moving bribery money through the office that guards the government's finances, and both still hold their posts. Nobody in the administration has addressed that. The judge's parting observation, that people here told him corruption is how business is done, was the most damning testimony of the week, and it came from the bench. The letters suggest he was quoting accurately.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Martinez Sentenced to 10 Years (June 9, 2026), St. Thomas Source: O'Neal Gets 7 Years in Latest Public Corruption Sentencing (June 11, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Government Witness Who Pleaded Guilty, Testified Against 3 Public Officials Gets 22 Months (June 10, 2026)
Two men dead at a Peter's Rest bar, and a 15-year-old killed on Vester Gade
Wahili James, 31, and Samuel Rivera, 34, died in a 3:45 a.m. Sunday shooting at Luna Bar that wounded two others, including a minor. Friday afternoon, Tre'Vante Etienne, 15, was shot dead in Charlotte Amalie, the territory's 17th homicide of the year.
The week opened and closed with gunfire. At about 3:45 a.m. Sunday, June 7, a shooting at Luna Bar in Peter's Rest on St. Croix, which police said began as a verbal altercation, left Wahili James, 31, and Samuel Rivera, 34, dead, and wounded two others, a 30-year-old man and a minor, both reported stable. The deaths were the eighth and ninth homicides on St. Croix this year.
On Friday afternoon at 2:17 p.m., ShotSpotter alerted 911 to multiple rounds on Vester Gade in Charlotte Amalie. Officers found a teenage boy with multiple gunshot wounds; he died at Roy Lester Schneider Hospital. Next of kin identified him as Tre'Vante Etienne, 15. His death is the eighth homicide on St. Thomas and the 17th territory-wide this year, by the Source Homicide List's count. No suspect information was available in either case by week's end.
The Health Department offered mental health support Saturday as the community mourned the teenager. The count has moved from 14 to 17 in two weeks, and the investigative appeals remain the standing ones: the Criminal Investigation Bureau and Crime Stoppers.
What is not being said: A 15-year-old was shot to death in the middle of a Friday afternoon in the territory's capital, hours after the Legislature passed a sweeping gun bill written mostly to satisfy a Supreme Court ruling about lawful carriers. The bill's own critics made the point that nobody answered: the people doing the shooting are not in the permitting system. Seventeen homicides by mid-June, and the tools on offer are a tip line, a mental-health hotline, and a law aimed at people who fill out forms.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Two Dead, Two Injured in Shooting at Peter's Rest Bar (June 7, 2026), St. Thomas Source: 15-Year-Old Dies After Shooting on Vester Gade on St. Thomas (June 12, 2026), St. Thomas Source: DOH Offers Mental Health Support as Community Mourns Teen Killed in Friday Shooting (June 13, 2026)
The gun law rewrite passed: shall-issue permits, banned accessories, and a 15-round line
Bill 36-0144 replaces the police commissioner's discretion with objective criteria and deadlines, expands legal carry while listing sensitive places, and bans ghost guns, .50-caliber rifles, and suppressors. Two senators voted no, and both sides expect to be back.
The 36th Legislature on Friday approved a comprehensive overhaul of Virgin Islands firearms law, replacing the territory's discretionary permitting system, under which applicants had to show special need and the police commissioner decided, with a "shall-issue" framework requiring VIPD to license residents who meet objective criteria written into statute, with 45-day deadlines for license applications and 30 for registrations. The change answers the Supreme Court's Bruen decision and a pending U.S. Justice Department lawsuit over the territory's practices.
The bill expands where licensed residents can carry compared with current law while maintaining prohibitions in sensitive places including schools, government buildings, and hospitals. It bans or tightly restricts automatic weapons, short-barreled rifles and shotguns, ghost guns, .50-caliber rifles, suppressors, and conversion devices, and caps magazines at 15 rounds with limited grandfathering. "This act is about balance," Attorney General Gordon Rhea said.
The opposition's argument was not about balance but about aim. "These bills only burden law-abiding people who register, train, pay, wait, and try to obey," testified Virgin Islands Safe Gun Owners founder Kosei Ohno, arguing criminals will not hand VIPD fingerprints and a paper trail. Licensed dealer Ehren Henderson called the magazine limit among the most troubling provisions and warned a parent could face charges dropping children at school. Sens. Alma Francis Heyliger and Carla Joseph cast the two no votes, with Francis Heyliger saying parts of the bill are "trying to criminalize law-abiding citizens."
Critics also objected that the final substitute text circulated too late for testifiers to read it. The majority's answer came from Senate President Milton Potter: do not let "perfect be the enemy of the good." The bill, drafted severable so courts can strike pieces without collapsing the framework, went to the governor.
What is not being said: The bill was drafted to survive courtrooms, not shootings; its severability clause is an admission that parts of it are expected to fall. What the debate never produced is a number: how many of the territory's homicides this year involved a firearm that any provision of this law would have touched. Seventeen families could ask. The Legislature passed the bill it could defend in federal court, which is not the same thing as the bill that addresses Vester Gade.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Lawmakers Pass Sweeping Gun Law Overhaul Amid Debate Over Rights (June 12, 2026)
The PSC chair called WAPA's flagship generators an ill-advised experiment nobody else ever bought
David Hughes told the commission the Wartsila 32LG engines are the only ones of their type ever produced, that none have sold since, and that they are clearly not working out. St. Croix went entirely dark again overnight Wednesday, the fourth time in seven weeks.
The generators sold to the territory as its energy future got a blunt reassessment Tuesday from Public Services Commission Chair David Hughes: "They were somewhat experimental. And they are clearly not working out very well. And they have not sold another engine of this type to anybody since. They were probably an ill-advised purchase by WAPA." Asked whether Trinidad and Tobago runs the same units, Hughes said no one anywhere does.
Wartsila itself marketed the 2020 Virgin Islands contract as a first: the debut installation of its multi-fuel 32LG engine. Six years on, the engines have struggled to run on the cheaper liquefied propane that justified them, suffered what a WAPA official has called a catastrophic failure, and contributed to May's multi-day district-wide outage. This week a transmission failure on Wartsila 3 drove fresh rotating outages in the district. Outside consultants wanted to examine WAPA's Wartsila contracts for testing and warranty protections; the commission lacked the funds to pay for the review. CEO Karl Knight assured commissioners the provisions are in place, and said WAPA crews observed testing in Wisconsin of emergency generation bound for St. John.
St. Croix's grid supplied the week's other data point. At 2:17 a.m. Wednesday, June 10, VI Update's polling of WAPA's feed recorded 22,761 St. Croix customers without power, effectively the entire island, dark in the middle of the night for the fourth time since April 25. As with the prior events, no substantial press account followed by week's end.
The commission voted to hold the LEAC fuel rate at 22.2226 cents per kilowatt hour through September 30.
What is not being said: The territory's grid depends on prototype engines no other utility on earth agreed to buy, and the regulator that just said so out loud could not afford the consultants to read the contracts. Who signed the territory up to be Wartsila's beta test, what the warranty actually covers, and what recourse exists six years in are questions with documents attached, documents a $250,000 forensic audit was funded to examine three years ago. The audit remains undelivered. The experiments remain online, when they are online.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: WAPA's Wartsila Generators Are Unique Experiments, Officials Say (June 9, 2026), St. Thomas Source: St. Thomas-St. John Power Problems (June 9, 2026), VI Update outage dashboard (WAPA public feed, polled every five minutes)
Ferry riders will pay 66 cents more while the report saying the companies over-collect sits unadopted
The PSC approved a 90-day emergency fuel surcharge with fuel at $7.68 a gallon. The same meeting heard that the operators may be collecting $7 million a year beyond their allowed profit, from a report the commission has yet to accept.
St. Thomas-St. John ferry tickets carry an extra 66 cents for the next 90 days, the Public Services Commission voted Tuesday, granting most of the operators' request for a 75-cent emergency fuel surcharge as fuel prices, driven by the war with Iran and the Hormuz closure, reached $7.68 a gallon. Commissioners briefly weighed 60 or 65 cents before landing on 66; how the companies derived their own figure was one of several numbers nobody could quite verify.
The surcharge passed against the backdrop of a draft report that says the companies are collecting roughly $7 million a year more than the 8 to 10 percent profit Virgin Islands law allows on about $85 million in annual revenue. Chair David Hughes suggested the fuel relief could come out of that excess rather than from passengers, but the report has not been formally accepted by the commission, and the operators' attorneys filed last-minute objections commissioners had not had time to read.
The deeper problem is that the commission cannot see the business it regulates. An attempted audit of fuel consumption per route failed; "We have data integrity issues and this is a big number that needs to be checked," Hughes said. The companies jointly own the ticketing system, which the rate examiner has said makes ridership and revenue impossible to verify independently.
Hughes floated a restructuring worth watching: once the finances are actually known, make ferry travel free for children and seniors, possibly for all residents, with visitors paying around $11 to carry the cost. "It's an opportunity to do something special for the Virgin Islands residents," he said.
What is not being said: The commuters of St. John will pay the surcharge starting now; the question of whether the companies have been over-collecting $7 million a year stays parked in an unadopted report with unread objections. That sequencing, riders pay immediately, findings wait indefinitely, has been the pattern of this investigation since it began. The free-rides idea is genuinely interesting, and it depends entirely on financial visibility the operators have spent two years not providing.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Ferries to Add 66 Cents-Per-Ticket Emergency Fuel Charge (June 9, 2026)
44,335 lethal doses in a hollowed-out book, and 500 rounds in checked luggage
A St. Croix man pleaded guilty to mailing 88.67 grams of fentanyl to the island, enough to kill roughly its whole population. A St. Thomas man was charged after allegedly flying from Miami with 500 undeclared rounds he planned to sell.
Mario Felix, 36, pleaded guilty to smuggling 88.67 grams of fentanyl into St. Croix, concealed as 800 tablets inside a hollowed-out book mailed from Hollywood, Florida in December 2022 and intercepted by federal officers four days later, who traced it to Felix through fingerprints. At the DEA's two-milligram lethality benchmark, the shipment held 44,335 potentially fatal doses, roughly one for every year-round resident of St. Croix. The charge carries a mandatory minimum of five years and a maximum of 40. Felix's record includes drug and firearms convictions running back to 2010.
The week's other smuggling case came through an airport. Homeland Security officers detained Kareem Eric Casimir, 32, who allegedly packed 500 rounds of ammunition, 9mm, .380, .40, and .223, split between his suitcase and a companion's on a flight from Miami, and told investigators he bought the ammunition in Florida to sell in the territory, according to court records. He was charged with failure to declare a firearm to a common carrier and released on $10,000 bond. The court records leave two open questions the coverage flagged: how the bags cleared Miami, and why the companion, who allegedly knew of the bullets, was not charged.
Both cases are allegations except where pleaded: Felix has admitted his conduct; Casimir has not been convicted.
What is not being said: The ammunition that feeds the territory's shootings arrives the way these 500 rounds allegedly did: bought legally stateside, undeclared, and flown or mailed in. The week's new gun law regulates none of that; it is federal territory. A man boarded a plane in Miami with 500 rounds nobody caught until St. Thomas, and the public record does not say how. That gap, the one between Florida's gun counters and the territory's crime scenes, is the supply chain, and no bill passed this week touches it.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: St. Croix Man Attempted to Import 44,000 Lethal Doses of Fentanyl (June 11, 2026), St. Thomas Source: St. Thomas Man Planned to Smuggle and Sell 500 Bullets, Police Say (June 8, 2026)
The territory sued the pharmacy middlemen
The Virgin Islands alleged national pharmacy benefit groups broke consumer protection laws, joining the wave of jurisdictions challenging how prescription drug prices are set. (St. Thomas Source)
Elections appeals ground on
The Board of Elections debated candidate appeals, residency requirements, and nomination rules in a Monday session, continuing the disputes left from the disqualification wave, including the documentation fight over Delegate candidate Ida Smith's St. John address. (St. Thomas Source)
KIDS COUNT: graduation and employment up, child well-being still strained
New KIDS COUNT data showed territory gains in graduation rates and employment alongside persistent child well-being challenges, a mixed picture mirrored nationally. (St. Thomas Source)
Ronald Russell lay in state at the Legislature
Colleagues honored the former Senate president as he lay in state in the chamber he once led, a month after his death. (St. Thomas Source)
The first solar day-care is done, five more out for bid
The Energy Office completed its first solar day-care project and sought bids for five more sites, small-scale resilience while the big grid struggles. (St. Thomas Source)
A woman died at Salt Pond, and answers came slowly
Police said a St. John woman found at Salt Pond appeared to have drowned, after an initial report that offered few details. (St. Thomas Source)
Glamping at Magens Bay
The Magens Bay Authority board heard proposals for glamping accommodations and cultural tours at the territory's most famous beach. (St. Thomas Source)