Good Day, This Week — No. 018, June 21–27, 2026

An automated news digest and analysis, operated by Brian Louden. VI Update.

The Democrats debated at CAHS: an app, a $4.7 billion question, and 'four thousand, at the Department of Justice'

Roach, Plaskett, and Frett-Gregory took the first debate stage of the cycle Friday, agreeing WAPA needs rebuilding and EDC needs a dashboard, and disagreeing about whose experience and whose administration the problems belong to.

The Virgin Islands Area Labor Federation hosted the cycle's first gubernatorial debate Friday at the Charlotte Amalie High School auditorium, putting the three Democratic candidates, Lt. Gov. Tregenza Roach, Delegate Stacey Plaskett, and former Sen. Donna Frett-Gregory, through two hours on collective bargaining, health care, accountability, and the economy ahead of the August 1 primary.

The recurring pressure point was Roach's eight years beside Gov. Bryan. When Roach committed to staffing the Office of Collective Bargaining in his first 100 days, Frett-Gregory asked why the administration he serves cannot do it now; Roach answered that the chief negotiator "serves at the pleasure of the governor and follows his directives." In his closing, Roach ran the other way, questioning Plaskett's management experience: "the most you probably run is an office of maybe 10 persons." Plaskett's reply was four words: "Four thousand, at the Department of Justice."

On WAPA, all three want reform; the paths differ. Frett-Gregory would pursue a public-private partnership in her first 100 days. Plaskett questioned the sequencing: "Until WAPA is regenerated with the 4.7 billion that I was able to receive for the Virgin Islands, how are you going to attract a private sector company to come in and do a generation program?" Frett-Gregory pitched a resident-grievance mobile app for potholes and streetlights; Plaskett called it a good first step but said "an app is not going to solve the problem" without personnel and funding behind it.

The consensus item was EDC transparency: all three endorsed a public dashboard showing what beneficiaries actually deliver, with Roach adding he would end the rule that lets companies count imported workers as residents after a year. Roach also proposed reopening the Limetree refinery. The full debate is on YouTube, and two more names were not on stage: the primary ballot's other contests, and the six independent tickets waiting in November.

What is not being said: The debate's sharpest fact went unexamined: the sitting lieutenant governor spent the evening campaigning against the record of the administration he still helps lead, and nobody on stage or at the moderators' table asked what he tried and failed to change from inside it. Every WAPA answer assumed the $4.7 billion arrives and works; no candidate was asked what they do in year one if it does not. The rotating outages that resumed this week were the unnamed fourth participant.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Democratic Governor Candidates Discuss Key Issues in First Debate Before Primary Election (June 26, 2026)

A third of Water Island, leased for 99 years: the resort proposal met its public

The Legislature heard divided testimony on amending the 2014 lease into a 180-acre, $300 million-plus resort with an 88-room hotel, marina, and 90 residences. Residents support a hotel at the old footprint; the chief counsel listed legal problems senators cannot skip.

The biggest land decision on the territory's table got its Committee of the Whole hearing Friday: a proposal to amend and reinstate a 2014 ground lease putting about 180 acres of public land on Water Island, more than a third of the island, under a 99-year lease for a resort development requiring at least $300 million in private investment, with updated cost estimates of $400 to $440 million. Plans call for an 88-room luxury hotel, a marina at Flamingo Bay, about 90 residences, workforce housing, a retail village, and new police, fire, and EMS facilities, with Honeymoon Beach staying under government control. Water Island Development Company would remain lessee with Blue Water Global Advisors as lead developer.

The developers' pitch: roughly 200 permanent jobs averaging $75,000, millions annually in hotel and property taxes, self-contained infrastructure including desalination, wastewater treatment, waste-to-energy, solar, and batteries, with residents free to connect voluntarily.

Water Island's residents drew a careful line. Civic association president Chuck Nestrud said the community supports replacing the hotel Hurricane Hugo destroyed in 1989, at its roughly 48-acre footprint, not a 180-acre lease that converts public land into fee-simple luxury housing backed by what he called a "totally inadequate" $3 million performance bond against a $440 million project. Marine scientist Stephan Bitterwolf warned senators about Flamingo Pond's mangroves, seagrass, and stressed reefs, noting the lease requires no specific mitigation. Residents also said the administration's one virtual meeting with the island was limited and never publicly noticed, and asked for a real town hall.

The Legislature's chief counsel, Amos Carty, gave senators the legal map: the 2014 lease was terminated in 2025 for nonperformance and later rescinded during negotiations, with no evidence presented that the breach was cured; federal deeds restrict parts of Water Island to public purposes, with sale proceeds owed to the U.S. government unless agreed otherwise; and provisions letting the Property and Procurement commissioner approve additional site leases and convey residential lots without further legislative approval may conflict with Virgin Islands law. Several senators said they cannot support the agreement as written. No votes were taken, and the same week, Government House convened leadership to discuss advancing the lease alongside hospital, WAPA, and Waste Management debt solutions.

What is not being said: A lease terminated for nonperformance in 2025 is back on the table a year later, larger, longer, and with less legislative control, and the hearing established that nobody has shown the original breach was ever cured. The $3 million bond against a $440 million project means that if this developer fails like the last arrangement did, the territory's remedy is less than one percent of the project's cost, secured against a century of its land. Water Island's residents asked for the one thing that costs nothing: a noticed public meeting on their own island. As of this week they have a virtual call that was not publicly announced.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Proposed Water Island Resort Lease Faces Scrutiny at Senate Hearing (June 26, 2026), Government House: Governor Bryan, Lieutenant Governor Roach and 36th Legislature Discuss Financial Solutions (June 26, 2026)

WAPA is running on its reserves, and the reserves are the rotating outages

Units 15 and 23 are offline, Unit 27 is running below capacity on a faulty fuel valve, and two Wartsilas are in repair. The board approved a $275.8 million FY2027 electric budget while Knight said rotations may continue whenever demand outruns what is left.

The utility's Thursday board meeting laid out the arithmetic behind the week's rotating outages on St. Thomas and St. John. "The main issue that we're faced with today is loss of generation capacity and insufficient generation capacity," CEO Karl Knight said. "We're basically using our reserve capacity right now, and so we don't have a lot of room for equipment malfunction without having to shed load." Units 15 and 23 remain offline, Unit 27 runs below rated capacity on a faulty fuel valve whose replacement was expected within days, and two Wartsila engines sit in repair with the manufacturer's technicians on island.

The shortfall is modest and decisive: about four megawatts at midday, four to eight at evening peak, when two feeders may rotate. Solar has trimmed daytime load shedding, though Saharan dust has cut output. Knight pushed back on reports that rotations would run three months: "We're not predicting rotations. We are basically saying that this is a possibility because we are in the summer."

The board unanimously approved WAPA's FY2027 budgets, $275.8 million in electric expenditures with balanced cash flow and a water budget projecting an $800,000 surplus, after management corrected an error in the prior week's presentation. Gov. Bryan, meanwhile, told the public that major recovery projects remain on track amid the fresh outages, and Government House convened legislative leadership Thursday to discuss financing solutions for the legacy debt of WAPA, the Waste Management Authority, and the hospitals, the structural arrears underneath every operational failure.

VI Update's polling of WAPA's feed recorded the week's peak Tuesday morning: 16,948 St. Thomas customers out at 9:43 a.m.

What is not being said: A grid whose margin is four megawatts is a grid where one machine's fuel valve decides whether sixteen thousand homes have power, and that is the situation the budget the board just approved is built to manage, not to end. The candidates debating WAPA's future Friday night did so in a district that had rotated feeders that same week. The distance between the $275.8 million operating budget and the transformation everyone promises is the distance between keeping the lights mostly on and never having this conversation again.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: WAPA Says Rotating Outages May Continue as Board Approves FY2027 Budget (June 25, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Bryan Says Major Recovery Projects 'On Track' Amid Fresh Round of Outages (June 23, 2026), VI Update outage dashboard (WAPA public feed, polled every five minutes)

A woman found dead in the Danish cemetery, a murder at Mahogany Run, and a licensed gun owner charged at Sion Farm

Philomen Winston, 69, was the territory's 23rd homicide. By Friday night, Pedro Melendez Sanes was dead at a St. Croix gas station and Brian Schooler, a licensed firearm owner, was charged with first-degree murder, arrested at the scene.

The violence continued into its third week. On Monday morning a caller found Philomen Winston, 69, dead in the Danish cemetery in Hospital Ground on St. Thomas, bleeding from the face with wounds about her body; police suspect foul play. Her death is the territory's 23rd homicide of the year by the Source Homicide List's count, and the 11th on St. Thomas.

On Thursday, police announced they suspect murder in the death of a man found at Mahogany Run Villas. And on Friday evening at 7:07 p.m., ShotSpotter and 911 calls brought officers to the WMJR Service Gas Station near Sion Farm on St. Croix, where Pedro Melendez Sanes was found with multiple gunshot wounds and pronounced dead at the scene.

The Sion Farm case broke the season's pattern in one respect: an arrest, immediately. Police identified Brian Schooler at the scene and charged him with first-degree murder, first-degree assault, reckless endangerment, and discharging a firearm. Schooler is a licensed firearm owner, police said. Bail was set at $1 million, and unable to post it, he was remanded to the John A. Bell facility pending a Monday hearing. The charges are allegations; he has not been convicted.

What is not being said: A 69-year-old woman beaten to death in a cemetery drew a fraction of the attention the month's gun deaths did, and her case has no ShotSpotter timestamp to anchor it. The Sion Farm arrest, meanwhile, will become an exhibit in the gun-law debate for both sides: the shooter was licensed, which opponents of the new law will note the permitting system did not prevent, and supporters will note the system is what identified him. Neither argument helps the two families.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Police Identify Woman Found Dead in Hospital Ground; Foul Play Suspected (June 22, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Licensed Firearm Owner Charged in Fatal Sion Farm Gas Station Shooting (June 27, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Police Suspect Murder as Man Found Dead at Mahogany Run Villas (June 25, 2026)

The Tootsys defendants were evicted from the house at the center of their own indictment

With trial set for July 13, a hearing stalled for lack of Spanish interpreters, the government moved to declare the case complex, and the judge spent his orders on a practical problem: how a jailed defendant retrieves his belongings, and his surrendered passport, from Bolongo 25.

The Tootsys case produced an unexpected development this week: eviction. During a Wednesday hearing that could not proceed substantively because Spanish interpreters were not present, the court learned that defendants Hussein Jamil and Julio Hidalgo de Pena had been evicted from the property at 25 Bolongo Bay, the residence where, per the indictment, many of the club's dancers lived and where the alleged operation kept its rules.

Jamil, the Source reported, has been granted pretrial release and is living with court-approved custodians, while Hidalgo de Pena remains in custody, and needs to retrieve his property from the residence, including the passport he was ordered to surrender to the court. Magistrate Judge G. Alan Teague agreed he should be able to, and by Thursday had issued orders directing defense attorneys and prosecutors to meet by Friday to agree on a protocol for the retrieval, reporting back by June 29.

The larger scheduling question hangs over the July 13 trial date: the U.S. Attorney's Office has moved to declare the matter a complex case, which would give prosecutors more time to develop and present it, and almost certainly move the trial. Teague said the motion is before him. Assistant U.S. Attorney Natasha Baker reminded the court that jury selection remains, for now, on the calendar.

What is not being said: The eviction raises a question nobody at the hearing voiced: the women who lived at Bolongo 25, the alleged victims the indictment describes paying $100 to $200 a week to stay there, were housed where, by whom, once the landlord cleared the property? The docket tracks the defendants' belongings and passports. The record of what happened to the women the case is nominally about is not public, and a complex-case designation means their wait for trial just got longer.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Judge Orders Legal Teams to Meet, Sort out Unexpected Development in Tootsys Nightclub Case (June 24, 2026)

The territory says an unlicensed therapy group billed Medicaid for after-school snacks as psychotherapy

A False Claims Act suit alleges RTS Services and three providers collected over $408,000 in reimbursements they were never licensed to bill, out of nearly $4 million claimed, mostly for services to children.

Attorney General Gordon Rhea filed a civil suit alleging nearly $4 million in Medicaid fraud by RTS Services Unlimited 11, LLC and providers Melinda Richards, Ashley Doway, and Duane Robinson, who the complaint says provided psychotherapy, hypnotherapy, and counseling, primarily to children with behavioral and mental health needs, without the licenses Virgin Islands law requires to render or bill those services. The suit says they collected more than $408,000 in reimbursements between January 2020 and 2026.

The complaint's most striking allegation concerns program design: RTS and its affiliated nonprofit, Passport2Prosperity, advertised after-school and summer programs offering homework help, tutoring, snacks, and transportation, none of it Medicaid-reimbursable, and allegedly obtained reimbursement by characterizing those activities as psychotherapy and behavioral health services. RTS and Richards held licenses for testing, evaluation, and consultation, the complaint says, but not for the therapeutic services they billed.

The Justice Department's Medicaid Fraud Control Unit began investigating in 2024, reviewing claims data, licensing records, and witness statements. The suit under the Virgin Islands False Claims Act seeks recovery of all funds paid, civil penalties, and disgorgement. The allegations are civil claims, not criminal charges, and have not been proven.

The suit landed in a week thick with health care money problems: the Budget Committee reviewed Frederiksted Healthcare's request amid growing uninsured care, the hospital board advanced its system-integration and redevelopment projects, and the governor's debt summit put hospital uncompensated care on the same ledger as WAPA's arrears.

What is not being said: If the complaint is right, children with genuine behavioral health needs spent up to six years receiving services from providers not licensed to give them, in a territory whose corrections director just testified that mentally ill residents are her biggest challenge and whose behavioral health system has no capacity to spare. The suit seeks the money back. Nothing in a False Claims action evaluates what happened to the children, and no agency has said it is checking.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: V.I. Sues Psychotherapists, Alleging Nearly $4 Million in Medicaid Fraud (June 24, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Budget Committee Reviews Frederiksted Healthcare Inc. Request Amid Growing Uninsured Care (June 22, 2026)

O'Neal reports July 1; the delay request mostly failed

Former OMB Director Jenifer O'Neal, who sought a two-month surrender delay amid a shakeup in her representation, was given until July 1 to report to federal custody for her seven-year sentence. (St. Thomas Source)

A tsunami advisory came and went after Venezuela quakes

Powerful earthquakes off Venezuela briefly put the territory and Puerto Rico under a tsunami advisory Wednesday before it was canceled, a live drill for the notification systems in hurricane season. (St. Thomas Source)

Delegate candidates fought over lobbying disclosures

Congressional candidates sparred over lobbying disclosures as the five-way Democratic primary for Delegate turned to who has represented whom in Washington. (St. Thomas Source)

Caneel Bay proposals got more time

The National Park Service extended the deadline for proposals to redevelop the Caneel Bay resort, pushing the July 8 date as interest in the St. John property develops. (St. Thomas Source)

The giant billboard is unplugged, for now

The proposed digital billboard on Rhymer Highway was shelved after public comment ran against it, a rare clean win for the opposition, with the caveat in the headline: for now. (St. Thomas Source)

WICO projects 1.25 million cruise passengers

The West Indian Company projected 1.25 million cruise passengers for the FY2027 season, continuing the growth its board reported in April. (St. Thomas Source)

St. John Celebration crowned its queen and opened its village

Elizabeth Ferrell was crowned 2026 St. John Celebration Queen as the island's festival season built toward the Fourth, with VIPD issuing its annual celebration advisory. (St. Thomas Source)