Good Day, This Week — No. 022, July 19–25, 2026
An automated news digest and analysis, operated by Brian Louden. VI Update.
HUD suspended VIHFA: 'blatant mismanagement, empty promises and abject failures'
The federal government cut off the agency running the territory's $1.9 billion housing recovery, citing 29 percent spent in nine years, more than half of that on administration, a convicted COO, and rotted lumber. Bryan is appealing and asked everyone to stop talking about it.
The territory's housing recovery hit its gravest institutional crisis Monday when the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development suspended the Virgin Islands Housing Finance Authority from receiving federal funds, effective immediately, pending an Inspector General investigation. HUD Secretary Scott Turner's statement was written for headlines: organizations "riddled with corruption, mismanagement, and crime will no longer be allowed to squander billions," adding that VIHFA officials "cannot be allowed to prioritize kickbacks over helping families recover from disasters."
The 13-page suspension letter is the most damning federal document the recovery has produced. Nine years after Irma and Maria, it says, VIHFA has spent less than a third, 29 percent, of the $1.9 billion appropriated to it, and 55 percent of what it did spend went to its own administrative costs, a gap the letter calls evidence the agency "is not presently a responsible program participant." It recounts former COO Darin Richardson's $107,000 kickback conviction and the lumber his contractor was paid to manage: "VIHFA's neglect then allowed that lumber to rot in the tropical sun." The pace of recovery is described as "glacial to practically nonexistent," and April's fraud-controls audit, the letter says, "suggests that no improvement is likely."
The government's response took shape across the week. VIHFA said it has already addressed many cited issues; the territory has 30 days to contest and has appealed. By Friday, Bryan drew the load-bearing distinction: the suspension is an "entity-level administrative matter" that does not reach the $1.9 billion already obligated, homeowners, contractors, and subrecipients "should continue to work." The White House was coordinating a meeting between the territory, VIHFA, and HUD. But he acknowledged the stakes for everything after: future CDBG allotments and affordable-housing funds run through the suspended entity.
Bryan's other request was quiet: "Throughout this process, we are asking everyone involved to have limited public comment," he said, warning against politicizing the appeal. Candidate Plaskett issued a statement anyway, saying she had engaged Republican congressional leadership ready to support an acceptable plan and would meet with Bryan and the Legislature. Media on Friday's briefing were not permitted questions.
What is not being said: Every fact in HUD's letter was previously public, the audits, the Richardson conviction, the spending rates, and the territory absorbed each one without structural change; what changed Monday is that Washington stopped absorbing them. A governor asking for 'limited public comment' eight days before a primary about who manages federal money is asking for something the calendar cannot give him. And the deepest number in the letter is not the 29 percent spent; it is the 55 percent of that spent on administration, which means for every dollar that reached recovery work, more than a dollar went to the agency delivering it.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: HUD Cites 'Blatant Mismanagement,' 'Empty Promises and Abject Failures' in VIHFA Funding Suspension (July 20, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Bryan: HUD Funding Suspension Does Not Extend to $1.9 Billion Already Obligated (July 24, 2026), St. Thomas Source: VIHFA Says It Has Already Addressed Many Issues Cited in HUD Funding Suspension (July 21, 2026)
A bill in Congress would end birthright citizenship in the territories for children born after 2026
Weeks after the Supreme Court reaffirmed the Citizenship Clause for the states, Rep. Morgan Griffith introduced legislation premised on the Insular Cases: what Congress granted by statute, he argues, Congress can take away.
The scenario territorial advocates warned about after Trump v. Barbara arrived within a month. Rep. Morgan Griffith of Virginia introduced the End Birthright Citizenship for Territories Act, which would amend the statutes conferring citizenship at birth in the U.S. Virgin Islands, Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Northern Mariana Islands for children born on or after January 1, 2027. It would not strip anyone's existing citizenship; it targets the unborn.
The bill's theory is the exact vulnerability this digest flagged when the Supreme Court ruled: because Virgin Islanders' citizenship flows from an act of Congress rather than settled constitutional recognition, its sponsor claims Congress can repeal it. "Just like Congress possesses the power to grant the territories constitutional rights in statute, we have the power to take them away in statute," Griffith said, citing both the Barbara decision's silence on territories and the Insular Cases directly. Vice President Vance, asked about limiting territorial birthright citizenship by executive action, had called it "a great idea."
Right to Democracy's Neil Weare called the legislation "dangerous and unconstitutional" and identified a drafting reach beyond its stated intent: though Griffith's office says children of citizens would keep citizenship, the statutory amendments "are sweeping, and could mean that anyone born in a U.S. territory starting in 2027 would no longer be recognized as a U.S. citizen, indeed, may not be a citizen of anywhere." The group also notes the bill would amend the Northern Marianas covenant, which was negotiated to require mutual consent.
The measure is early-stage: introduced, not advanced, needing House, Senate, and a presidential signature. Its significance is not its odds but its existence: the first legislative test of whether territorial citizenship is a right or a revocable grant, introduced while the territory's own delegate seat is on an August ballot.
What is not being said: For 109 years the territory's citizenship has rested on a statute nobody tried to repeal, which allowed everyone to treat it as permanent. The bill will likely die in committee, and that will be reported as reassurance. It is the opposite: a live demonstration that the legal theory works, waiting only for a Congress willing to use it. The permanent fix, constitutional recognition that the Fourteenth Amendment reaches the territories, requires either the Supreme Court overturning the Insular Cases or a constitutional politics the territory cannot vote in.
Ten people ordered into dark water off an uninhabited island: the smuggling route through St. Thomas, in one night
A smuggler allegedly abandoned five Ecuadorians, four Indians, and a Dominican man on Culebrita with no food, water, or flotation, mid-route from Tortola through St. Thomas toward the mainland. One woman nearly drowned. All ten survived.
Before dawn Monday, ten people were ordered off an inflatable Zodiac into rough, dark water off Culebrita, a tiny uninhabited island near Culebra, and told to swim for a shore they could barely see. None had flotation devices. An Ecuadorian man told Customs and Border Protection agents he could not swim and was "extremely scared"; witnesses described a small Indian woman who nearly drowned until another migrant held her above chest-high water. The ten, five from Ecuador, four from India, one from the Dominican Republic, were found stranded on Culebrita Beach at about 7:30 a.m., uninjured.
The man agents stopped at 3:55 a.m. near Culebra's Mosquito Bay, Gregory Vega-De Jesús, claimed he had bought the boat in St. Thomas for $11,000 that morning; agents found three phones and about $7,000 aboard. He has a prior migrant-smuggling conviction and eventually told agents where he had left the ten, according to court records. He was charged Tuesday under federal smuggling statutes. The charges are allegations.
The route the migrants described is the story's map: one Ecuadorian said he paid a contact called Nano Car $18,000 for passage through Panama, the Dominican Republic, Tortola, St. James, and St. Thomas, with Puerto Rico and the mainland still ahead. Three others said they paid $3,000 each for the St. Thomas-to-Culebra leg alone. The territory is not the destination; it is the corridor, the same waters where the Tootsys indictment describes women moved through the BVI, and where a Coast Guard interceptor killed a boater in May.
What is not being said: St. James, the island in the middle of that $18,000 itinerary, is the Epstein estate's island group, which says something about how thoroughly the smuggling corridor runs through the territory's geography, indifferent to who owns the waypoints. Federal enforcement caught this boat and killed a boater in a channel in May; the corridor absorbs both outcomes and keeps operating. Ten people nearly drowned Monday for the crime of wanting to reach Minneapolis and New York. The man who allegedly left them there was home by breakfast.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Alleged St. Thomas Smuggler Abandoned 10 on Uninhabited Island (July 22, 2026)
FEMA says the entire wastewater system is beyond repair. The $3.2 billion to replace it has barely moved.
VIWMA told senators full replacement is anticipated by 2034, with roughly $3 million spent so far, a collapsed 42-inch main under Cancryn, $300,000 in pumps destroyed in two months, and a chairman concluding the authority has no real plan.
The sewage crisis that has run through this digest since April got its comprehensive hearing Wednesday, and the numbers are staggering in both directions. The system: 240 miles of pipeline, 4,200 manholes, 31 pump stations, eight treatment plants, of which FEMA has concluded "all wastewater infrastructure is beyond repair" and "cannot be patched or rehabilitated. It requires replacement." The money: approximately $3.2 billion in FEMA funding identified for full replacement, anticipated complete by 2034.
The spending to date, senators learned, is roughly $900,000 in St. Thomas-St. John and $2 to $2.5 million on St. Croix, design work and early pump purchases, against $3.2 billion. Wastewater chief Walton Keith Smith said the authority is on track if it keeps its pace; Committee Chair Ray Fonseca reached the opposite conclusion: "I don't think the Waste Management Authority has a real plan, and any deadlines to spend the $3.2 billion." Firm design and construction schedules requested by the committee were not available at the hearing.
The present-tense failures kept arriving as testimony: about 1,000 feet of 42-inch gravity main near Cancryn has collapsed underground, forcing temporary pumping; unreliable power has destroyed more than $300,000 in pumps in about two months; and sewer lines were not replaced when First Avenue in Sugar Estate was recently rebuilt, meaning the new road may be torn up again. Fonseca called that "unacceptable."
The hearing also surfaced the problem the $3.2 billion cannot legally touch: private laterals, the pipes connecting homes and businesses to the mains, which FEMA money cannot fund and which Fonseca warned could require hundreds of millions more, or the new public system will have failing private pipes feeding it. Smith's public-health framing was unambiguous: overflows expose residents to bacteria, viruses, and parasites, with children, the elderly, and pregnant women most vulnerable.
What is not being said: Put this hearing beside Monday's HUD letter and the shape of the territory's real risk is visible: the second-largest pot of recovery money in the territory's history is moving at a pace of roughly $3 million spent against $3.2 billion available, administered by an authority a Senate chairman says has no plan, in the exact posture that got VIHFA suspended. Nobody at the hearing said the word HUD. The federal patience that ran out for housing this week is the same patience wastewater is spending.
The teen who killed Dutty Heart will serve no more than 15 years under a plea deal
Angela Javier Carmona, 15 at the time of the boardwalk shooting that killed comedian Jordan Jones, will plead to second-degree murder, after a judge found him competent and declined to strike the first-degree charge over his age.
The killing that stunned St. Croix in June 2025 is ending in a plea. Angela Javier Carmona, who was 15 when police say he shot comedian Jordan "Dutty Heart" Jones, 38, in a midday robbery over a gold necklace on the Christiansted boardwalk, signed an agreement July 17 to plead guilty to second-degree murder and serve no more than 15 years, with credit for pretrial detention. The government dismisses the remaining counts; Carmona stipulates the evidence proves he shot Jones and waives challenges to the searches and statements in the case. A change-of-plea hearing was continued to August 10 for revisions.
The legal road to the deal ran through two hard questions about trying children as adults. Court-ordered evaluations initially found Carmona partially or not competent, findings the court determined were "grounded... on his youth and inexperience" rather than mental illness; Judge Venetia Harvey Velazquez found him competent in May. His public defender then argued the first-degree murder charge, carrying mandatory life without parole, could not constitutionally apply to a juvenile under U.S. Supreme Court precedent that the Virgin Islands Code does not reflect; the judge denied the motion July 7. The plea mooted the appeal that argument was headed toward.
Jones's death produced grief at a scale the territory reserves for its beloved: last year's Frederiksted fireworks were held in his honor, the final rocket carrying his ashes.
What is not being said: The Virgin Islands Code still contains a mandatory juvenile sentence the U.S. Supreme Court has said cannot be imposed, and the gap was resolved here by prosecutorial discretion rather than legislative repair, meaning the next 15-year-old's outcome depends on the next prosecutor. A boy who was too young to buy the necklace he killed for will leave prison around 30. Both halves of that sentence are the territory's youth-violence crisis in miniature, and neither half was anybody's policy.
Early voting neared the all-time record with five days to spare, while the racetrack deal stalled in special session
4,064 Democrats, 19 percent of active registrants, voted early by Friday, 91 percent of 2022's full-period record. The Legislature pushed the Southland gaming bill to an August hearing, and the elections board hired its own lawyers.
The primary's turnout signal is strong: 4,064 active Democrats had voted early by Friday, 2,012 on St. Croix, 1,965 on St. Thomas, 87 on St. John, reaching 91 percent of 2022's record full-period total with five days of early voting remaining through July 29. "Their sacred vote is secure," Supervisor Fawkes said, a sentence that doubles as a campaign message for her own embattled office. The primary is Saturday, August 1.
The special session Bryan called for the revised horse-racing agreement produced a punt: senators pushed the racetrack and gaming bill to an August hearing rather than vote, taking Sen. Gittens's careful-review posture chamber-wide. The deal's improved terms, five-year promoter commitment, no gross-receipts exemption, doubled horsemen's share, were not enough to overcome the appetite for scrutiny that this year's procurement record has earned.
And the elections board formalized its independence: following the attorney general's recusal, it voted to seek independent counsel in the McClafferty suit, meaning the territory will now pay outside lawyers to defend an election administration whose own internal authority dispute remains unresolved, with the August 26 federal hearing approaching.
What is not being said: Record early turnout in a primary whose administration is in federal court, whose board is at war with its supervisor, and whose biggest week of news was a federal suspension of the housing agency, voters are not disengaged from this government's performance; they are responding to it. The candidates who spent the week asking for limited public comment about HUD may want to check what the lines at Sunny Isles and Lockhart Gardens are commenting on.
Sources: St. Thomas Source: Early Voting Tops 4,000, Nears 2022 Primary Record (July 24, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Senate Pushes Racetrack, Gaming Bill to August Hearing in Special Session (July 21, 2026), St. Thomas Source: BOE Votes to Seek Independent Counsel in McClafferty Suit, Following AG (July 20, 2026)
A man was found dead with multiple gunshot wounds
Police opened another homicide investigation Tuesday after a man was found dead with multiple gunshot wounds, in a week that also brought a critical wounding at the Glynn Service Station and a VIPD warning after nine burglaries were reported in a single day. (St. Thomas Source)
O'Neal's release motion got a clock
The Third Circuit set a deadline for the government's reply to Jenifer O'Neal's motion for release pending appeal, as the convicted former OMB director's challenge to her seven-year sentence took shape. (St. Thomas Source)
Contour will fly St. Thomas to St. Maarten nonstop
Contour Airlines announced nonstop service between St. Thomas and St. Maarten, a regional connectivity gain in the year the territory lost Spirit. (St. Thomas Source)
NOAA put the territory in extreme drought
A NOAA report detailed extreme drought in the USVI amid dry conditions across the region, the context for the territory-wide burn ban and a hurricane season that has stayed mercifully quiet. (St. Thomas Source)
The cancer institute hired a radiation oncologist
Sen. Fonseca announced the Charlotte Kimelman Cancer Institute has hired a radiation oncologist as health officials detailed the CKCI reopening timeline to his committee, progress on a promise long deferred. (St. Thomas Source)
A 68-room hotel was proposed at Mount Welcome
Stonehouse Junction LLC sought rezoning for a new 68-room hotel at Mount Welcome on St. Croix, joining Club Med and the Water Island proposal in a suddenly crowded hotel pipeline. (St. Thomas Source)