Good Day, This Week — No. 024, August 2–8, 2026

An automated news digest and analysis, operated by Brian Louden. VI Update.

The Senate approved the 99-year Water Island lease, 11-3, with the federal question still unanswered

The amended deal keeps Honeymoon Beach public, requires $300 million-plus in investment, and replaces a statutory 60-acre veterans and housing set-aside with 20 condos at $250,000. Interior has not yet responded, and construction-period rent is $1,000 a month.

Water Island's century got decided Tuesday. Meeting as a Committee of the Whole, the Legislature voted 11-3 to approve Bill 36-0340, reinstating and amending the 2014 lease with Water Island Development Company for a five-star resort on about 144 acres of government land: an 88-room hotel, marina, spa, roughly 90 branded residences, workforce housing, and at least $300 million in private investment including $40 million in infrastructure. The 99-year term carries a $3 million performance bond, a 6 percent government share of residential sales, and rent that starts at $1,000 a month during up to five years of construction before rising to $120,000 and then $240,000 annually. Sens. Fonseca, Francis Heyliger, and Gittens voted no. The bill goes to Gov. Bryan.

Property and Procurement called the amended agreement "substantially stronger," and by the loudest measures it is: Honeymoon Beach and its catchment return to government control. But the hearing's unresolved questions passed into law with the vote. Legislative counsel reminded senators the island came from the Interior Department under quitclaim deeds restricting it to public purposes, with sale proceeds owed to Interior absent a written agreement; the government has contacted Interior about the amended lease "but has not yet received a response." The developer's own attorney conceded residential land sales require separate federal approval the territory does not have.

The sharpest exchange concerned the land the law already promised to someone else. Acts 6751 and 7321 require 60 acres of Water Island transferred to the Housing Finance Authority with 15 percent for veterans; the lease instead deems that obligation satisfied by 20 developer-built condominiums, 10 for veterans, 10 for middle-income buyers, at $250,000 each, exclusive for two years. "Under any analysis, is that a fair swap? Sixty acres for 20 condominium units?" resident attorney Isaac Northup asked. Sen. Dwayne DeGraff, himself a veteran, did the acreage: "You cannot develop more than 140 acres. You have to leave 60 acres by law." Sen. Marvin Blyden argued the other side: a Water Island home otherwise costs "over a million, easy," making $250,000 "an opportunity."

Civic association president Chuck Nestrud's summary stood as the residents' epitaph for the fight: "To say this lease will fundamentally alter Water Island forever is not an exaggeration." Days later, the island celebrated something older and simpler: the grand reopening of Fort Segarra, the public heritage site, to visitors.

What is not being said: The Legislature approved a lease whose residential core requires federal permission nobody has, replaced a 60-acre statutory promise with a two-year window on 20 condos, and set construction-period rent at $1,000 a month, less than many Virgin Islanders pay for an apartment, on 144 acres of public island. If Interior says no to the land sales, the territory has committed a century of its island to a hotel wrapped around an impossibility. The three no votes came from the senators who asked exactly that question and did not get an answer.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Senate Approves 99-Year Water Island Resort Lease 11-3 Despite Public Land, Housing Concerns (August 4, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Water Island Residents Celebrate Grand Reopening of Fort Segarra (August 6, 2026)

The absentee count locked the top of the ticket and flipped the Senate order underneath it

Plaskett-Potter finished at 4,678 and Sarauw at 5,095 as counting closed toward certification. Avery Lewis overtook Marvin Blyden for the St. Thomas-St. John lead, and the four-vote seventh-place fight stayed unsettled to the last ballots.

The primary's final arithmetic arrived in the absentee count. Monday's processing of 385 ballots reinforced the top: Plaskett-Potter grew to 4,678 unofficial votes over Roach-Francis at 3,150 and Frett-Gregory-Moorehead at 2,060, and Janelle Sarauw widened her Delegate margin to 5,095 over Delia Smith's 3,125. Certification follows the final count.

The reshuffling happened where the margins were thin. Absentee voters pushed Avery Lewis past Sen. Marvin Blyden into the St. Thomas-St. John lead, 2,808 to 2,395, with Carla Joseph claiming third; Ray Fonseca slipped to sixth, and the race's tightest fight, Joel Browne Connors versus Peter Bailey for the seventh slot, tightened to six votes, 1,442 to 1,436, with 231 district absentees still out at Monday's close. On St. Croix, Kurt Vialet's lead only grew, finishing the count above 3,690, with Gittens, Clifford Joseph, and Williams-Jackson behind him.

The winners turned immediately toward November: the Democratic nominees face six independent gubernatorial tickets, and voter registration for the general reopened August 6. The Board of Elections' next task is certifying results from a primary that, whatever else this season broke, produced record participation and a clean count.

What is not being said: A Senate seat may turn on six votes, which is the strongest argument anyone has made all year for the machinery fights this digest has tracked: signature rules, inactive voters, absentee deadlines, and board authority stop being abstractions when the margin is smaller than a family. The supervisor and board who spent the summer suing and shouting delivered, on the evidence, an orderly count. Both things are true, and November's margins may be thinner.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Absentee Ballots Reinforce Top Democratic Races, Reshape St. Thomas Senate Order (August 3, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Candidate Responses: Democrats Turn Toward November After Primary Victories (August 2, 2026)

The new executive order writes the territories' citizenship theory into federal policy

Trump's August 6 order denies citizenship to anyone born 'in a territory... where citizenship is not conferred by Federal statute,' adopting the framework that makes Virgin Islanders' status a statute Congress could amend, as the Griffith bill proposes to do.

The escalation this digest tracked from the Supreme Court's June ruling through July's Griffith bill arrived at the White House. An August 6 executive order, Continuing to Protect the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship, lists categories of U.S.-born children to be denied citizenship, and its fourth category is the territorial one: persons born "in a territory or territorial waters of the United States where citizenship is not conferred by Federal statute." The order changes nothing for Virgin Islanders today, whose citizenship is conferred by statute, and everything about the official theory of what that citizenship is.

Delegate Plaskett called the provision "a troubling escalation," warning that if Congress changed the statute, Virgin Islanders could land in American Samoa's position: U.S. nationals, not citizens. Right to Democracy's Neil Weare read the order as an invitation: "What began as a legal theory... is now being invoked as a road map for Congress to limit the right to citizenship in these communities." The road map has a vehicle already moving: Griffith's End Birthright Citizenship for Territories Act, which its sponsor's website celebrates as "the only step we can currently take."

A companion order the same week targeted "birth tourism," a phenomenon the Migration Policy Institute estimates at perhaps 22,000 to 26,000 births annually while the order's actual sweep, the institute calculates, would deny citizenship to roughly 255,000 babies a year. Both orders rest, as Weare noted, on the Insular Cases: "That's the only basis for this." The president, signing on camera, said the Fourteenth Amendment was meant only "for the babies of slaves."

The territorial provision will be litigated with everything else in the orders. What it has already accomplished is on paper: the executive branch of the United States now formally distinguishes between "the United States" and "a territory of the United States" for the purpose of who is born American.

What is not being said: Each step in this sequence, the court's silence, the bill, now the order, has been individually dismissable as symbolic, and the sequence itself is the story: a theory is being normalized in every branch at once. The Fourteenth Amendment line the president delivered on camera, that it was meant only for the babies of slaves, describes the amendment that is the sole constitutional basis for citizenship in a territory that is 76 percent Black. Nobody in the territory's government has said what its plan is if the statute is ever amended, because there isn't one. The plan is Congress's mood.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Civil Rights Advocates See Worrying Signs in New Trump Citizenship Order (August 7, 2026)

Arthur A. Richards opened: $264 million, three years late, and the template for $5.2 billion more

The first new public school in more than 30 years cut its ribbon Friday, at nearly double its original estimate, with the recovery director promising lessons learned that 'we will never, ever, ever, ever, ever do again.'

The territory opened its first newly built public school in more than three decades Friday: the Arthur A. Richards PreK-8 on St. Croix, rising from the site of the demolished Evelyn M. Williams Elementary. "For more than 30 years, we have not built a new public facility of this magnitude," Education Commissioner Dionne Wells-Hedrington told a standing-room ceremony. "Today, we are not simply catching up, we are setting the bar." Students arrive Monday, August 10.

The bar's price is part of the record: estimated at $159 million with a two-year timeline when demolition began in 2022, the project finished at $264 million, swollen by change orders and Education Department additions, with the federal government obligating $232 million and the balance repurposed from another school's funds. It stands as the recovery's second-largest completed project, behind only the $338 million composite-pole installation. Disaster Recovery Director Adrienne Williams-Octalien was disarmingly candid about the tuition paid: "We learned so many lessons about what we want to do in this recovery, as best practice, and what we will never, ever, ever, ever, ever do again. But we learned it on this project so that it can catapult us forward."

The forward is enormous: more than 17 schools under construction or in design, representing $5.2 billion in education projects, including Charlotte Amalie High School, Central High, and the new Sprauve School on St. John. Gov. Bryan closed the ceremony with Roosevelt's man in the arena, lingering, twice, on "who errs."

What is not being said: A 66 percent cost overrun on the first project of a $5.2 billion program is either the price of learning or the program's run rate, and which one it is will be visible in the next school's change orders. The candor about never-again mistakes was genuinely unusual for a ribbon cutting, and it stopped short of a number: nobody said what the lessons cost, which other school lost the repurposed funds, or who approved the additions. The children get a beautiful school either way. The auditors get the template.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: New Arthur A. Richards School Opens on St. Croix After Multiyear Build (August 7, 2026)

A hedge fund manager says the governor's tax team punished him for winning his refund

Bill Perkins's federal suit claims that after he sued and collected $1.34 million, the BIR disallowed his $3 million RTPark credit without review, and quotes a 2022 Bryan text: 'I think it's totally unacceptable that we pay any EDC company a return.'

The territory's tax administration became a federal First Amendment case this week. Bill Perkins, the St. Thomas hedge fund manager behind Brisa Max Holdings and Skylar Resources, sued Gov. Bryan, the government, and Bureau of Internal Revenue officers, alleging a retaliation campaign that began after he sued for, and in August 2024 collected, a $1.34 million delinquent refund. Within two months of that payment, the suit says, he was hit with a notice of deficiency for the same year, after a BIR supervisor handed his file to an agent with a directive to disallow his nearly $3 million Research and Technology Park credit, which the agent did without substantially reviewing the documents.

The complaint's most consequential line is attributed to the governor himself, in a 2022 text to a tax attorney: "I think it's totally unacceptable that we pay any EDC company a return. After we have given them a 90% reduction of their tax liability." As a sentiment, it is one many Virgin Islanders share; as an instruction operating on a specific taxpayer's file, it is the suit's theory of the case. Perkins claims First Amendment retaliation for petitioning the courts, selective enforcement, and due process violations, and demands a jury. The government had not responded by week's end; the claims are allegations.

The context the suit sits in is the one this digest has tracked all year: ordinary Virgin Islanders wait years for refunds without the means to sue, EDC beneficiaries' obligations are enforced unevenly, and now the territory faces the argument that when it finally did scrutinize a beneficiary aggressively, it did so as punishment. Perkins's own history, litigation over refunds since 2017, a fortune estimated up to $500 million, a $15 million painting, guarantees this case will be well-lawyered on both sides.

What is not being said: If discovery substantiates the text message, the case stops being about one rich man's credit and becomes about whether tax enforcement in the territory is policy or mood. The uncomfortable symmetry: the government position quoted in the suit, that EDC companies with 90 percent reductions should never see refunds, is probably popular, and applying popular positions to individual files without review is precisely what tax law exists to prevent. The residents who wait years for refunds without lawyers should watch how fast this one moves.

Sources: St. Thomas Source: Suit Claims Bryan Tax Team Targeted Multimillionaire (August 5, 2026), St. Thomas Source: Millions at Stake in Federal-or-Local Tax Dispute as it Heads to Court (August 8, 2026)

The grid's perfect week lasted exactly one week

After primary week's 25-customer peak, the feed recorded 15,867 St. Thomas customers out Wednesday, a Thursday midnight territory peak of 18,247, and 10,484 on St. Croix Saturday, alongside planned overnight bypass work.

The remarkable calm of primary week, a territory-wide peak of 25 customers, did not survive August's first full week. VI Update's polling of WAPA's feed recorded 232 individual outages across the week, with St. Thomas peaking at 15,867 customers out on Wednesday, August 5, the territory's peak reaching 18,247 just after midnight Thursday, and St. Croix closing the week with 10,484 out on Saturday, August 8.

Some of the darkness was deliberate: WAPA scheduled overnight outages for eastern St. Thomas and St. John as the Feeder 13 bypass project continued, the resilience investment whose completion will give the eastern district a backup power path. The rest was the familiar arithmetic of a generation fleet still waiting on its temporary FEMA units, with the standby generators promised for St. John and the Fortuna Solar Farm's year-end target now the nearest dated commitments on the board.

The week's budget hearings kept the utility's institutional context in view: the Waste Management Authority faced questions on proposed user fees and aging infrastructure, and the Casino Control Commission on audit findings, the semi-autonomous agencies' season of accounting continuing while the biggest one's forensic audit, funded three years ago, remains undelivered.

What is not being said: One week of near-perfect service proved the grid can do it; the next week proved it cannot do it twice. The difference between 25 customers and 18,247 was not weather or a hurricane; it was ordinary Tuesday-to-Saturday operation of the same machines. Until the temporary generation arrives, that variance is the product, and every quiet week is a coin that landed well.

Sources: VI Update outage dashboard (WAPA public feed, polled every five minutes), St. Thomas Source: Overnight Outage Planned for East St. Thomas, St. John as WAPA Continues Major Bypass Project (August 5, 2026)

The territory joined a $400 million generic-drug settlement

AG Rhea announced a settlement in principle with Sandoz over conspiracies to inflate generic drug prices, part of antitrust litigation built on 20 million documents and cooperating executives who described "playing nice in the sandbox." The territory's expected share: about $228,000. (St. Thomas Source)

UVI made Forbes' top HBCU list while defending its budget

Forbes ranked UVI among the nation's top HBCUs the same week the university sat before the Budget Committee to discuss its request and its show-cause accreditation status, with the September 1 deadline approaching. (St. Thomas Source)

Early-morning armed robberies hit St. Thomas

VIPD sought the community's help after a series of early-morning armed robberies on St. Thomas closed the week, as the department launched an opt-in security camera registry, the civilian extension of the network that cracked the Charles case. (St. Thomas Source)

NOAA trimmed the hurricane outlook again

NOAA reduced its 2026 Atlantic outlook further as El Niño strengthened, with CSU maintaining its well-below-normal forecast, even as the NHC began monitoring two Atlantic areas late in the week. (St. Thomas Source)

The U.S. opposed O'Neal's release bid

Federal prosecutors opposed Jenifer O'Neal's latest motion for release pending appeal of her seven-year corruption sentence. (St. Thomas Source)

Gittens's VIPD manpower bill advanced

Sen. Gittens's bill securing additional manpower for VIPD moved forward, codifying the cross-agency deputization the governor ordered after Officer Charles's killing. (St. Thomas Source)